🔴 The 4 biggest decisions behind a paid newsletter

This year, we've profiled dozens of newsletter operators running various business models — a pricing consultant with 85,000 subscribers, a court-records reporter with 10,000 subscribers, a tastemaker who left Substack to build his own platform, among others.

We pulled some of their best tactics into a playbook organized around four decisions every newsletter operator has to make: what to charge, how to grow, what to sell, and what you’re building beyond the inbox.

— Natalia Pérez-González, Assistant Editor

Every single YouTube channel should also have an Open.Video channel.

Open.Video provides the ownership, direct export access to subscriber lists, and all benefits that come with owning your channel. Take away some of YouTube's control over your channel and instantly sync it to a channel tailored to your goals.

From then on, it's automatic: publish to YouTube exactly as you do today, and the same video appears at your address, on your player, under your brand.
Then change one habit. Put the URL you own in the bio, the newsletter, the pinned comment, the media kit — and let YouTube keep doing what it's unbeatable at: reach.

One-click YouTube auto-sync — new uploads automatically mirror to your domain.

MRSS and direct upload — .MP4, .MOV, and .MKV land wherever a feed or a file does.

Nothing locked — keep your YouTube channel; Open.Video is additive.

Get started at Open.Video in less than 10 minutes.

This is an advertisement.

There’s no single blueprint for building a newsletter business.

beehiiv just analyzed thousands of paid newsletters to find out what the business looks like in 2026. Subscription revenue grew 138% last year, but what a newsletter can earn — and how — varies enormously by niche, audience, and execution.

Across the operators we’ve profiled this year, the same decisions keep surfacing.

Kyle Poyar, creator of Growth Unhinged, advises software companies on pricing for a living, and still underpriced his own newsletter at first.

He’d chosen a number that felt good to charge, rather than asking what the placement was worth to the advertiser. Looking back, he thinks he could have charged 50% more.

CPM prices an ad based on every 1,000 impressions. That's useful when reach is what you're selling. It's less useful for small, valuable audiences.

Kyle's newsletter reaches CEOs and software decision-makers, so if a sponsor can turn that audience into a six-figure deal, the value of the placement isn't captured by how many thousands of people saw it.

Rule of thumb: The more niche and commercially valuable your audience, the more you should be pricing to what one advertiser stands to make.

Kyle sells sponsorships quarterly rather than one placement at a time. Each partner gets:

He also caps the number of sponsors he'll accept. Limited inventory makes the product more valuable and gives him room to raise prices as demand grows.

One sponsor's webinar generated 500 signups and six figures in pipeline from a single send. That's a much better pricing signal than CPM.

The best newsletter ads shouldn't feel interchangeable.

Kyle works with companies he'd plausibly mention without a sponsorship and pushes advertisers to give readers something useful rather than simply promoting themselves. The goal is an ad that still delivers value if nobody buys anything.

Disclosure: Creator Spotlight is owned and operated by beehiiv, one of Kyle's ongoing sponsors.

Put it into practice:

Dan Oshinsky, founder of Inbox Collective, has been working on newsletters since 2012, first at BuzzFeed, then at The New Yorker, and then as a consultant since 2019. Few people have had such a close view of how the newsletter business has evolved into what it is today.

When he launched newsletters at BuzzFeed, growing a list was simple: signup boxes at the bottom of stories, a few house ads, and a site pulling tens or hundreds of millions of visitors a month.

Over the past year, the biggest change his clients have faced is traffic — less of it from search, far less from social — and the teams that built their whole growth strategy on converting site visitors need to diversify their acquisition channels.

Dan asks every new client two questions:

In working with The Leakey Foundation, for example, Dan saw a newsletter built like countless nonprofit sends: blog posts, field updates, a donation ask. Its real asset, though, was its access. The foundation funds leading researchers in human evolution, so Dan is now helping turn that network into a publication that explains human behavior through evolution and animal science.

Rule of thumb: Most newsletters are assembled from the content an organization already has. The ones worth forwarding are built from something only that organization can reach.

Rather than treating every subscriber identically — voter, parent, volunteer, or operator — ask what they care about, and trigger automations based on their answers. A survey response can lead to a tailored sequence; a reader who's already told you what they want is someone you can make a much more specific case to.

And don't stop at the welcome sequence. Dan sees courses — automated sequences that teach a skill, habit, or lesson — as one of the biggest missed opportunities. A course gives someone a new reason to subscribe, then gives you several chances to deepen that relationship. The same logic can extend to renewal, churn, and abandoned-cart flows: a reader takes an action, and your newsletter responds accordingly.

Pro-tip: On beehiiv, you can start with signup flows and surveys.

Put it into practice:

Seamus Hughes, creator of Court Watch, has just over 10k subscribers and will generate around $100k this year. He doesn't pay himself any of it.

Court Watch covers stories Seamus finds buried in federal court records, and its readership is unusually concentrated: federal judges, prosecutors in every US attorney's office, public defenders, Big Law partners, and reporters at nearly every major paper. Last year, 200 news organizations cited his reporting. His paid subscribers and revenue have each roughly doubled every year for three and a half years.

Court Watch’s readership includes federal judges, prosecutors in every US attorney's office, and reporters at every major paper — an audience so concentrated that advertisers or institutions would pay a premium to reach it.

Seamus won’t broaden his coverage to reach a bigger number; the moment you write for everyone, you stop being essential to anyone.

Seamus’ annual pitch is a state-of-the-newsletter post recapping everything Court Watch did that year, followed by one email a day for five days. It reliably nets ~100 new paid subscribers each time.

Put it into practice:

Tyler Bainbridge started Perfectly Imperfect on Substack with two friends in 2020, a free newsletter sharing what interesting people were into. Six years later, it's a social platform with more than 400k users, adding six new recommendations a minute.

PI left Substack because the newsletter was only one part of what they wanted to sell. They needed readers to pay once for both content and app features, and they wanted community activity to flow back into the newsletter. Their existing platform couldn't do both, so Tyler and his co-founder — both engineers — built their own.

Until recently, building community around a newsletter meant sending readers somewhere else—a Discord, Facebook group, or separate membership platform. Every extra destination creates another login, another habit to build, and another place to lose people.

Pro-tip: beehiiv's Community feature closes that gap natively — spaces tied to your list, published posts syncing into a newsletter channel, and the option to gate spaces to paid subscribers.

Put it into practice: