🔴 What makes you trust a creator?

In partnership with

Brought to you by beehiiv.

Trust is a creator’s most valuable currency. It’s what grows and maintains an audience; what earns a paid subscriber, what advertisers buy into.

Today, I lay out the foundation of how it’s built and sustained.

— Natalia Pérez-González, Assistant Editor

Everyone needs an editor — we built one for you

The best way to use AI for writing is as an editing partner.

Especially if you don't have another person to edit your work and tell you what works and what doesn't.

When writing Creator Spotlight, we'll often paste our drafts into AI tools, asking what to cut, what feels repetitive, or what's just getting in the way. But … the advice we get back from these tools isn't often helpful.

In partnership with Perplexity Computer, we turned that workflow into a focused editing tool: The Wordcount Terminator. The suggestions are specific, and in the right voice, so we can quickly see what actually needs to change instead of sifting through generic advice. And the Learn feature even rounds up great writing examples to help us keep learning and get sharper as an editor, not just faster.

(And if your problem is the opposite — your writing needs more instead of less — our tool can help with that too.)

Give it a try.

This is an advertisement.

Trust is a creator’s most valuable currency

There are two major lifestyle creators who consistently govern my TikTok and Instagram feeds, and who have, over time, earned my complete trust.

Tefi Pessoa, @hellotefi to nearly two million followers, a Colombian-Brazilian creator from Miami whose devoted audience has branded her “the internet's big sister.” And Monet McMichael, a Jersey-raised beauty it-girl and nursing-school grad who went full-time creator and BeauTuber.

Both operate in the same universe, command enormous audiences, and wield major currencies in this economy: attention and trust. Attention compounds reach, but means little without trust.

In Tefi we trust, is a running bit in her comment section.

She'll dissect the breakup of Fleetwood Mac in one video (she’s beloved for her several-part breakdowns on celebrity relationships) and, in the next, drop a winded, earnest plea (“let me hold your hands while I say this”) to stop texting the person who keeps letting you down. (She now writes an advice column for The Cut, Ask Tefi.)

@hellotefi
Angelina Jolie lived rent-free in my head…watch this weeks of @Tefi Talks on YouTube or watch on your favorite podcast platform!! #angelin... See more

Monet’s get-ready-with-me videos consistently pull millions of views, and I can’t help but marvel at her editing style. I’ve often spent hours watching her videos; her calendar reads like a beauty-brand atlas: Fenty, Dior, Lancôme.

Millions of people stop scrolling for each of them, myself included. I've bought the blush Monet swears by, and I've carried Tefi's advice to help navigate many personal situations. Their energy catches my attention, but my trust in them is what prompts my continual investment.

The hierarchy of trust

For creators who are selling their judgment and taste — advice, curation, analysis, a recommendation the audience will act on — trust is critical, completely foundational.

After many conversations with creators and studying their businesses, I've come to see trust as built in a hierarchy from the bottom up.

For creators, trust is the currency earned by proving your values over time. Trust is what audiences give you in exchange for the feeling of belonging.

It starts with your values: what you actually stand for before anyone's watching.
Then legibility: your ability to make those values clear and evident.
Then consistency: legibility over time.
Then accountability: proving those values even under pressure, when it costs you something.
And at the very top, belonging: the point where an audience starts treating you as part of who they are.

Notice the shift that happens at the top of the trust pyramid, as values made legible and and proven durable over time create belonging. The bottom four rungs are all things the creator does — actions, broadcast outward. Belonging is what the audience builds back, in response to everything below it. You can't manufacture belonging directly, but you can build the infrastructure for it by consciously stacking the rungs beneath it.

Audience belonging is most durable when it’s built on a shared reality others can clearly understand and participate in. Communities can and do form without that foundation, but those relationships often look like parasocial attachment, one-way devotion untested by disagreement or change.

When the hidden reality finally surfaces — like an undisclosed sponsor, revealing the creator’s values as disingenuous — the whole thing collapses at once. We've all seen it happen.

Ultimately, trust is about establishing a shared reality and making it legible to other people. In a fragmented media environment, trust becomes less about universal agreement and more about alignment. Creators thrive in this ecosystem because they offer audiences a coherent set of values, an interpretation of events that feels consistent and believable, and an approach to making sense of the world they can subscribe to.

Trust in practice across creator archetypes

All creators depend on trust, but the stakes of that trust vary dramatically from one archetype to the next.

There’s the advice creator, who tells you how to do something with stakes attached — the personal-finance explainer, the fitness coach, the career or parenting voice. Follow bad advice here and you lose money, time, or worse.
The curator, who tells you what's worth your attention or money, the reviewer, the tastemaker, the "I bought it so you don't have to" voice. Their whole value lies in their calibrated taste and clean incentives.
The analyst, who tells you what something means — the markets commentator, the tech explainer, the one making sense of the news. You're trusting their read on reality, which is the most fragile thing to lend out and the easiest to bend.
The practitioner, who teaches the craft they actually practice — the creator-journalist, the founder, the marketing director, or lawyer posting from inside the field.
The guide, who doesn't just inform but convenes — the community builder whose audience has become a place. Here, trust is already mutual, and belonging is doing the work.

Spectacle creators trade in attention — you don't necessarily need to trust MrBeast to watch a video, you just need to be entertained.

It helps to think of this less as two camps and more as a spectrum, sorted by a single question: how much time and/or money is the audience being asked to hand over?

At one end sits pure spectacle — you watch, you're entertained, and nothing leaves your hands (other than, of course, your time). At the other end sits pure delegation, where you act on the creator's word at real cost to yourself. The further a creator moves toward that end, the more trust becomes central to the entire product.