Transcript 0:00 We did something like four or five million clicks last year were sent out to other people's websites. You have a couple large social media accounts. You are doing CPM deals, so you're charging per thousand views. 0:11 That's how you're making the bulk of your money here. Even if it only gets 1,000 clicks, let's say you have 20 CPM, that's 20 bucks right there from 1,000 clicks. But if that gets 10,000 clicks, that adds up. 0:21 This whole clipping ecosystem, can you give this sort of like, "Here's how it works"? Right now it's Wild Wild West. Welcome back to the Creator Spotlight podcast. 0:32 My name is Francis Zierer, and today we're speaking with Zach Williamson, the man behind a few massive Twitter or X accounts, notably Culture Crave with 957,000 followers, and Latest In Space with 1.3 million followers. 0:46 He has been in the social industry for well over a decade now. He's very good at this. He also has a bit of an inside look at the clipping economy. So we get into that. Really good conversation. Enjoy. 0:59 In an interview for the Indie Hustle newsletter a couple of years ago, you said that when you started working in social media, which you've been doing a little over a decade, you saw accounts posting links that you knew they were being paid to post. 1:12 You figured you could build an audience, do the same thing, and within four months, you had built an account to 100K followers. 1:19 Within eight months, which I'm curious if that's including or after that four-month point, but within eight months you hit one million followers. Mm-hmm. Was that account Culture Crave? Was it something else? No. 1:30 Was it Thrones Facts? No. This was... So this is an entirely different era. This was when, this must have been like 2012, 2013. I used to do things called theme pages. 1:40 So I think one of them, this was in the sports scene. We did some, like, humor-based ones. I had this one called, like, Stuff Drake Does that really blew up back then. 1:48 They were more just, like, gimmick style accounts is what I would say, where you're making content or curating content on. The news stuff, like Culture Crave, that all moved, um... 2:00 I don't think I started doing that until like 2017. Mm-hmm. And so back then it was more like, okay, you worked with these companies called like Cha Cha. 2:08 I don't know if you're familiar with them, but it used to be this plat- there used to be this thing where like you'd text them a number, or you'd text this number and it would like answer questions for you. Mm. 2:16 And then at some point they got into like affiliate marketing on, with working with like social media accounts. 2:22 And so that's where when I was looking at those links, they would have a Cha Cha like tracking code on it at the time. I didn't know what tracking codes were, but I would just see Cha Cha pop up. 2:32 Went down a rabbit hole, figured out what they were. You saw attention and money. [laughs] Yeah. I saw, okay, like these people are just posting this random stuff on these accounts, these random links. 2:40 Like it must be, there must be a reason for it. Even, even some of it felt automated. And so then I got in touch with their rep, just was asking them questions about it. 2:50 And like honestly, at that time I didn't even have a big enough following, but I just was like, "Hey, I have 100,000 followers. Like what do you guys work with for humor-based pages?" 3:00 And then they would tell you, "Hey, so we do like CPM based, so it'd be $8 to $12. If you can deliver X amount of traffic, you get higher CPMs," basically. Mm. So we're talking about this like 2012 to 2017. 3:13 We're talking about the era before you start Culture Crave, which is, you know, like sort of ostensibly the reason we're talking today. Mm-hmm. This is sort of like your training ground. 3:23 Let's talk about like where you are today, and then maybe we can go back in time again. So- For sure... you have a couple large social media accounts. They're especially large on, on... 3:32 I'll, I'll call it X, 'cause I think you relaunched Culture Crave. It, it existed in the Twitter era, and then you relaunched it in the X era. Mm-hmm. So we'll get into that. 3:39 But you've got Culture Crave, which has 957,000 followers on X. Latest In Space has 1.3 million. You have Culture Crave is on, is on, uh, Instagram, it's on Blue Sky, I think it's on Snapchat. 3:49 You're, you're sort of everywhere, but it's especially on X, and you make a lot of your money doing these sort of sponsored posts. You're posting links to articles on other sites. You're not... 4:00 It's a little, it's a little like, we talked about this when we first spoke, how it's almost like in a, as a Google Zero era, you are driving traffic to some of these, these outlets, these publications. 4:12 Getting a little over my skis though now. What do you do right now? Like let's say we're recording this, it's almost the end of June 2026, almost the end of Q2. What did you do in Q2? Like what are you up to right now? 4:25 Right now we're trying to... So we just launched the newsletter through Beehive again, relaunched it, hired a writer to help me do that just because it was just taking up too much of my own time. 4:34 So he's doing, he does drafts and he pitches over ideas, and then I pitch ideas, and then we have two designers who help with this content, and we both like verify the information or go through and find our own information for these things. 4:48 So I think like still right now it's just expanding, and then still just like we have a really good group of clients that we're working with. 4:55 We have a couple agencies that either have really good deals with studios or working with some studios directly. 5:01 I'm trying to find more video game companies to work with because I feel like that's a market that's not as... 5:07 I think that they just aren't doing as much social media stuff, even though like it's clear sometimes these games just blow up on social media. 5:15 You see these indie games that blow up on social media, and I don't know if all that's necessarily like human, human word of mouth. I think it's like people talking about it on social media that these things blow up. 5:25 And so we're trying to do more of that because I also think that that industry is not as small. Mm. When I say small, you have movie studios, there's six or seven mo- big movie studios now. 5:38 A lot of them are even getting bought by tech companies. They're also combining, you know, like with Paramount and Warner Bros, it's happening. That just happened a few years ago with Fox and Disney. 5:48 So you have less players who are going out and buying ads, and but they're all doing social media marketing, so you still wanna like be going in working with those guys. 5:55 Which, which to be clear, like the way you're working with these people is you are selling, because you have these large accounts where you can, you're very good at getting attention with these, right? Mm-hmm. 6:04 You are sell- you are doing- CPM deals, so you're, you're charging per thousand views. That's how you're making the money from there We do... I will do CPM deals if they're like, "Hey, we need millions of views." 6:17 Super down, like, that's usually the angle I'll go with. Because we will have to go and use more accounts than just Culture Crave. It's very hard to guarantee that, like... Unless they're open to several posts- Mm... 6:27 then I could say, "Okay, a million views, that's super doable." But like, for example, we just did a deal for Spider-Man: A Brand New Day, where they had this Spyou Tracker thing. 6:36 A super cool tracking tool that they're putting out Easter eggs. It's literally spyoutracker.com. 6:41 And they put out Easter eggs on it, they're following the press tour with Tom Holland and Zendaya right now, and the rest of the crew. And they've just put out stuff on there, and so they, we did a promotion for that. 6:51 And that was just a one-off post across all these things. And we've done a lot of different stuff with Sony. We've done a few of their animes, like we did Chainsaw Man last year. 7:00 And so we have, like, good rapport with them. And so we do those kind of things where they come to us and they're like, "Hey, we want to promote this. Here's like, here's the brief. What would you do with these images? 7:11 How would you present it? And we want it to be in your voice, in the same style as Culture Crave." 7:16 So we do those, and then we have also where companies come, like for example, Lionsgate came last year with a Stephen King movie. They did an adaptation of The Long Walk. 7:25 And they're like, "Hey, we're gonna send you a screener, and then we want you to just pitch ideas on how you'd market this." And so I watched it. Brutal movie. 7:33 [laughs] And, and then I read a bit of the book, and so in the book, they're walking 4.5 miles per hour, and I'm like, "Dude, that's impossible." Like, I went to the treadmill, tested it myself. In the movie, it's 3.5. 7:45 Yeah. So that was how we based our whole concept off, so I pitched them. I was like, "Well, let's do a breakdown. I'm gonna talk to some doctors. 7:51 I'm gonna, like, email people about this, and figure out how would that affect your brain. How does that affect your body day by day to do that?" So that was our pitch to them. 7:59 They really liked that, and they bought that. And then we had to go do the research and talk to doctors about this stuff. And that is my favorite thing. I love doing that kind of stuff. 8:09 I think that's very creative and more involved. I do love doing the other stuff too. 8:14 Like, if s- if Sony's gonna come to us and be like, "Hey, we want you to promote Spider-Man," we're gonna [laughs] you know, gonna say yes. But, but, but- Or whatever... 8:19 I mean, what you're saying here is that you're not doing, like, just, like, cheap volume, like, "Hey, we know to get- Mm-hmm... 8:23 views on Twitter by, like, phrasing our tweets right, and like, you know, making them provocative," and like, "Hey, that's what we have to offer you." 8:29 You're saying that you are doing these more sophisticated and d- and involved marketing- Yeah... campaigns. Like, that's the service- We do, we do both... you provide. Yeah. We'll do all of it. Like, I'll... 8:38 'Cause a lot of those kind of things, like, we'll get movies, man. This morning I got messaged by this agency we've been working with, and they were like, "Hey, do you wanna do Jackass today? Like, here's the brief." 8:49 And I just literally read it, and then they did a... They literally bought all these dudes stars up in, up in space, and they made a penis constellation. [laughs] And they're just like, "What would you do with this?" 8:59 And then I, like, pitched them my copy based off everything they did, and they, they were like, "Let's, let's run it," so we ran that. That took 10 minutes to get that through. 9:07 And so, like, I'll do those kind of things too, because at some... 9:10 A lot of these studios, what they do is they wanna do blitzes, which is where you're just putting out a lot of social media content right as the movie's coming out. Yeah. Or, like, within the week after it's coming out. 9:19 But- I, I see by the, by the way, I'm looking at this right now. It's l- live on Twitter five hours ago. Uh- Yeah... it d- has the paid partnership marker there. 9:26 100, um, excuse me, 1.1 thousand likes, 74,000 views, and then additional 15,000 views on the follow-up, uh, tweet with a link to- Mm-hmm... the website. The constellation, right? [laughs] Yeah, yeah. It's great, though. 9:39 Isn't that, like, such a fun campaign that they did? I- Yeah... you know, I love to get those. And this, like, I mean, ju- just to s- like, to- Yeah... 9:44 since I'm looking at your Twitter and I'm looking at these, like, there's a lot of posts today alone. The one at the top right, now you've got that one pinned, the one I just noted. Mm-hmm. 9:53 But the one right below it, which was posted 13 hours ago and you've since reposted, probably you've reposted it a couple times, has three million views, 102,000 likes. Uh, and this one, not a paid partnership. 10:05 It's about Obsession, and you're quoting from an article from Complex. And then, obviously in the follow-up tweet, you do link to the Complex article. 10:13 So this is j- just trying to give the listeners a sample of the sort of stuff that you're putting on the page. Yeah. Actually, with that one though, so I saw that one was going viral. I posted it last night. 10:23 I, I mean, it was a great interview. I watched most of it, and that's kind of like how we get a lot of our content, is actually watching these interviews. 10:29 And we get sent stuff all the time by journalists who are just like, "Hey, can you watch this and find something that you'd be interested in covering about it?" 10:37 And we can't guarantee we're gonna find something, but, like, that interview particularly, I thought that was super interesting that she wasn't working, and I think that gives a good look into an actor's life of... 10:47 You know, this w- this woman filmed this movie in two thou- 2024. Just came out, now it's going viral, but she couldn't get a job in between that time. And she was phenomenal. 10:55 I don't know if you've seen the movie, but- I haven't seen it, no... she steals the movie. It's, it's a great movie, dude. Probably, possibly my favorite movie of the year. Okay, well wait. 11:02 I, I want, I wanna go, let's, like, zoom back out a bit to just look at your business as a whole. 11:06 We've been talking about this one specific part, which is you having this Twitter account, um, with a large following, and this ability to see, whether in an interview or some assets shared with you, like, here are the bits that I know will hit with our audience and beyond and go viral, right? 11:21 That's the service that studios and particular agencies will come and pay you for. So that's one part of your business. But- Mm-hmm... what, what is the entirety of your business right now? 11:31 You're, you're selling this, this attention as a service, and some production as a service as well- Mm-hmm... posted through Culture Crave. What other ways are you making your money right now? 11:41 So that's the main way, but when we're talking about that Obsession post that you were just talking about, so that one I posted last night, it started going viral, and we linked straight to the YouTube interview with it w- for Complex. 11:53 But then I was like, "Wow, this already has 1,000 clicks. Maybe we should just do a writeup on it." 11:57 So Pop Culture News is this new expansion that we're, like, spinning off of Culture Crave and Latest in Space, and we're talking to Raptive, which is a big ad player, about doing just basically they'd put their ads all over a website. 12:10 And you basically are making money off of RPMs. Then we did a writeup on that last night. I don't know how many clicks it dr- I think it got like 4,000, 5,000 since last night. 12:20 And so we'll do, we don't write up everything that we post about. 12:24 We do a lot of links, like where it's just literally linking to wherever the source is, and I think we did something like four or five million clicks last year were sent out to other people's websites. 12:35 But now we're doing also where we will write our own, do our own interviews. We're doing some interviews now too and mixing those in. And then doing situations like that where I'm like, "Wow, this is going viral." 12:46 Like we might as well just write something up about it, and even if it only gets 1,000 clicks, like let's say you have 20 CPM, that's 20 bucks right there from 1,000 clicks. 12:54 But if that gets 10,000 clicks, you know, I think that adds up. And so that's something we're spend- expanding on with this right now. And like a lot of websites work the other way. 13:04 Like when I was at Rolling Stone, for example, or just even in the past, like you think about the website first and then you build your socials. But we're like, "Okay, we have these great socials. 13:13 Why not then go the other way and expand off of that?" And I think to me it's just like, I guess that's like a low-hanging fruit way to make some extra money off of this stuff. 13:24 But I also think that like a lot of websites need to be thinking about that more as you go forward with this world with AI and like how Google now, when you just Google something, it's not really recommending- It's Google 0. 13:34 Mm-hmm... articles. Yeah. It's not recommending... It used to be that everyone's playing for the SEO and they're playing for the Google search. 13:42 And now it's like you need to be thinking about how are you gonna get traffic five years from now? One of those ways is having great socials, one of those ways is having great newsletters. Mm-hmm. 13:52 And so that's what we're thinking about now and expanding. And then we do, we do have, like Facebook pays directly to post on their platform. We have a deal with Snapchat too to do content there. 14:04 I'm still figuring it out 'cause we just got bumped to their program called the Snap Star program. We were in the Publisher program before. News to me. Uh, Snapchat is a complete blind spot for me. 14:12 I haven't used the platform- Oh, it's an interesting world, man... since maybe 2017. Yeah, yeah. No, I, um, I'm still on Snapchat. 14:18 And they do kind of like, they basically have their own TikTok competitor where they just like basically swipe up, and so they've moved us into that area. 14:27 And then with Twitter too, you know, there's like the rev share with Twitter, but we're also in their X I should say. Whoa, wait, wait, wait. I wanna- Sorry... focus on X for a second... say X for this chat. 14:34 [laughs] But, but you, so you built Culture Crave on Twitter, and then, uh, in another interview you said that you rebuilt it from the ground up in June 2023. Mm-hmm. 14:43 And I think it was July 2023 that the name changed to X. So you built Culture Crave in the Twitter era and then rebuilt it in the X era. Yeah, so we had- What's the difference? The difference, so we had... 14:58 I started building Culture Crave, I think this is like 20- right after I graduated college. So this was like 2017, I think is when I first started it. 15:08 And then I had an agreement to sell it during the pandemic 'cause I was just like, "Well, it's just a feed," you know? And it's a, it's a very strong feed and it's worth a good amount of money. 15:17 So I had a deal to sell it. That ended up falling through, and I was able to get the rights back. They kept the old account and we relaunched it with Culture Crave, with all the branding and with all that. 15:27 And then I think it, we had a really good relaunch. Like we had a good plan, good launch video. 15:32 Um, we had all our other socials that we could use to push it, and I think we gained somewhere between 50,000 and 80,000 followers in the first day on the relaunch. 15:40 So it was just like, okay, we already have our base following. And I think when I go, um- How big was the old account when you sold it, do you know? 800,000. Wow. On Twitter. 15:50 Yeah, and it was just the Twitter really that they had acquired. 15:54 In as much as like you built something on Twitter and you've since, again, built a, a new version of the same thing on X, in terms of the platform and like the way the platform works, 16:06 these intricacies of it that you've had to figure out- Yeah... is there anything or is it just sort of the same as before and you just like, you know, experiment and experiment with phrasing and all these things? 16:16 What's different about X versus Twitter for the way you work, is what I'm asking? 16:19 I would say the biggest difference to me, man, is that Twitter era was way more chronological focused, and now it's, it's becoming more like all the other platforms, right? And I think- Post-TikTok. Post-TikTok. 16:31 TikTok's influenced everything where it's now what do we recommend to people versus like are we sending people what they follow? 16:38 But I still think Twitter is better than a lot of the other versions at still giving you what you follow. They give you options to make your own custom lists. 16:47 People actually turn on notifications for accounts on Twitter. It's still the best news platform in my opinion of all the ones we're talking about. 16:55 And so I still think that like there's a lot of things that they're doing pretty well, but yeah, it's more now recommendations and, and like even that, that post for Tomat last night with Obsession, that one had 20,000 likes in probably 45 minutes. 17:09 There is no shot that's all from our following. You know? Like but before, that probably wouldn't have blown up that fast like that. Yeah. It really wouldn't have been pushed out. 17:19 I think now it's very AI ran, it's very Groq ran, right? [laughs] So they're gonna see that this thing's going viral fast, and they're gonna start pushing that out to more people. So it's kind of interesting in that way. 17:31 I think I'd still would prefer that just anyone who follows me is getting my content versus- Yeah... these kind of slower... Not even joking, I think when I checked that last night it was, it was trending pretty well. 17:42 And we po- I posted it at probably 1:00 AM. I was literally getting ready for bed, and I had just finished up that interview and I was like, "That was a pretty good tidbit. I probably should run that one." [laughs] Yeah. 17:51 And finished up the copy, threw it on. 17:54 I was like wrapping up, getting ready for bed, then like checked one last thing before going to sleep at like 1:30 AM, and I see 20,000 likes already and I'm like, "Holy shit," you know? Okay. Check the link. 18:05 Already has driven a lot of traffic to Complex. I'm like, "Okay, I probably should write an article on this. This is something that- Potentially overnight, it could drive decent traffic to the website. 18:14 So then I did a, a write-up, or I had... I can't... Yeah, I did a write-up on that one. Yeah. Uh, outside of Twitter, so Culture Crave is on Bluesky, has- Mm-hmm... 271,000 followers there. On Instagram, 62,000. 18:27 Maybe you're on some other platforms too, but with those two platforms, neither one is seeing anywhere near the same level of engagement on the same posts as you are getting on X. 18:38 Tell me about how you view Culture Crave on these other platforms, what they do- Yeah... for you, if they do much for you at all. 18:45 Instagram, to me, I want to build more, but I'd have to hire someone specifically to just, hey, turn everything we make into a headline graphic style. Mm. 18:55 And we're talking about that right now, and that's actually something I'm talking to one of my designers about, where I'm like, "I might, we might just put you on that," you know? 19:02 And then just take every tweet that we make and convert that into a three or four style post because- Mm-hmm... with Instagram, you wanna do multi-slides because when you're- Shows up more often. 19:13 Yeah, it shows that it'll re-pop back up if someone's scrolled by it and it's an account they engage with, or they see that this account is getting shared a lot. They have all their recommendations. 19:21 I think that Instagram, for me, it doesn't drive a lot of traffic, and I, m- unless you're, let's say, you're like Pubity on Instagram. They're probably driving pretty good traffic 'cause they have 100 million followers. 19:31 But, like, I don't even know if they're driving as much traffic as Culture Crave's driving on Twitter with a million followers because people just don't... There's not really a good way to drive links. 19:41 I just saw that they rolled out this new feature that I think if you pay an extra 5 or 10 bucks a month, you can now start doing links in your posts. So they might start doing pay-to-play stuff like that. 19:52 And if they, if, if that becomes rolled out to us, I might try that- Yeah... to see, to experiment with that. But, uh, like a lot of these platforms, they don't want you to leave their platform. 20:02 They want you addicted to their content. Yeah. So they're not trying to have you leave the platform, right? Well, okay. Like- One, one, one that I don't think that's the case for is Bluesky. 20:09 Bluesky is ostensibly, you know, trying to be an antidote to many of these dark patterns on other platforms, and you've built a decent following there, but how's that working? How do you feel about Bluesky? 20:22 Yeah, so it's interesting, man, because they still don't have... They need more features. 20:26 You know, I, we actually have a rep now, and so I was emailing about this last week and I was just like, "Is there any timeline of when people are gonna get impressions?" 20:34 Because if I can have impressions on this post, I can take that to a client and say, "You guys should be on Bluesky." 20:41 For example, you should make your own socials on Bluesky because there's actually, like, it's something measurable. 20:45 That's what all, everyone wants to be able to measure what kind of traffic they're gonna get from there, right? And so, but they don't tell you link clicks. 20:54 They don't really tell you views, impressions, however anyone categorizes it. 20:59 I think the nature of it, though, is that it's, it's a, it is a Twitter clone, and so it has the same tendencies of how people view the content, right? So, like, even though they don't de... 21:09 Even though even if you did a reply or you do a link in the top, people still just aren't interested in clicking links anymore unless you really make it interesting. 21:16 And so, like, we found kind of funneling people to that. Like, you have a really interesting headline. The people who care are gonna go then click the link regardless, but if it just, if that post... 21:27 Like, let's say if I had done that obsession post with the link in top, I don't know if it would've gotten 40,000 or 100,000 likes or whatever it is now. It probably wouldn't have. No. 21:37 'Cause I don't think people are gonna click, care to click the link. You want zero-click content on there. Yeah, exactly. So, and I, even if Bluesky says that, "Oh, yeah, people don't..." 21:46 It's the same thing with Threads. Like, Threads is also the same where they say, "We're not de-linking. Like, we're not..." I, I forget what the word is. Like, throttling links, let's just call it that- Yeah... 21:57 'cause I can't think of a better term. But I even saw the CEO of this say recently, he's like, "We don't throttle anything." The Instagram CEO said, "We don't throttle this stuff. It's just people don't click 'em." 22:06 And that is the same, I think, with everything, and that probably is not... That's probably a problem that's been happening beyond just aggregators. Mm. 22:14 I think that's a problem that you'd look back 10 years ago is that everyone was just posting clickbait headlines. People just wanna keep scrolling. And this is also why- Yeah... 22:21 you, this is why your work works, is because you're good at pulling out the bit that people wanna see, and it's just the morsel, and then they can keep scrolling. Yeah, they can keep scrolling. 22:31 Or if you really care and you want more information, then you can still go in and find the link. And so- Yeah... that's why I was saying even that obsession one, it's driven... 22:38 If I check, it's probably driven somewhere be- it's probably gonna end up getting close to 10,000 clicks. 22:43 And it's just to me that, like, platforms and, and websites and if you're running your own website, you just need to learn and adapt and test, and that's what we've been talking about from the beginning is just keep trying things. 22:54 [upbeat music] If you're a creator, you probably did not get into this to spend hours uploading files, writing tags, organizing assets, and digging through analytics. 23:01 That's why Open Video built an MCP server just for creators. 23:05 It lets an AI agent manage the operational side of your video business from a single prompt, uploading, tagging, organizing, and analyzing your entire channel for you. 23:14 And unlike traditional platforms, it all happens on infrastructure you control. So let AI do the busy work while you do the important work of creating content your audience can't live without. 23:25 See how you can do more with AI at open.video/mcp. That's open.video/mcp. Uh, can you, can you explain to me a bit, like, this ecosystem? 23:37 You said, again, when we first spoke about doing this episode, you said that you're in a handful of these Discord servers and Telegram chats, and you know, like, 10 or so people who run these servers, servers. Mm-hmm. 23:47 And these are the oper- the operators, the orchestrators. Can you, you know, for the, the listener who maybe is not up on this whole clipping ecosystem, can you give this sort of like, "Here's how it works"? Okay. 23:59 We've been talking about it a little bit- Yeah... but I just wanna focus on that for a second of, like, what's going on here. Definitely. 24:04 So usually, a lot of these things are ran in Discord servers, and some of the more, I would say, are getting more professional. They've built out their own platforms. Even, like, MrBeast has one. It's called Vyro. 24:16 And let's say, let's use his for example. Viro, get views, make bank. That's how they advertise it. 24:22 So I'm in that one, for example, but I know for a fact with that one that they have sort of the ones that they publicize at the low CPMs, kind of like we're talking about a dollar, and then they have premium people that they also market higher CPMs to. 24:38 And so that's like an example of one server. 24:40 But then you have a lot of these Discords where they will just have like 10,000 users in there, and they just post the campaign and they say, "Hey, we have four million impressions that we're trying to drive. 24:51 Requirements are TikTok, Instagram, YouTube Shorts." Video, because this is gonna be a you- it's like probably a podcast clipping or let's say it's an artist that they just want you to put the music... 25:03 For example, like I saw this one the other day. It was like, "Let's just put Drake songs," or I, I can't remember if it was Drake, but Drake definitely does clipping. And I don't know if he's- Yeah... 25:11 he's obviously not the one who's doing this. It's his team that's doing this. But they would say, for example, something like, "Let's put Drake lyrics on an edit of Spider-Man," because Spider-Man's hot right now. 25:22 It's trending. So then you post that on TikTok. That might go viral, and your account might have 1,000 followers, but it might just blow up on TikTok because, um, that's just what happens on TikTok. 25:33 So that, I'd say those are like two examples, and then a lot of those are- But wait, one, one, one quick question about that. Yes. These exchanges, is it contract-based? Like how, what is the transaction here? 25:43 How does that happen? Yeah, so what you do is then either in that channel or if they have the website, you submit your links, they verify if the views are real, and then you get paid out based off the views. 25:56 So if you- But you go and make the video first. You go get the views- Yeah... and then you take them back- Mm-hmm... to the person who sort of put this assignment out. Yeah, and a lot of... 26:04 They, they, they can vary, so it could be that they want you to make the c- content, or they might provide the content to then post. They usually have rules, right? So it's like, hey... 26:14 A lot of them are honestly d- undisclosed. Like, we don't do any undisclosed stuff, but with these kind of campaigns. But, um, 26:21 a lot of that stuff can be undisclosed stuff, and it's just they, that's what they write if they want it to be more organic. This is the big... 26:26 I mean, uh, one way this has come into the media a couple months ago, there was the, the, the, all these articles around Geese, right? 26:32 I Like Geese, this, this rock band, and there was all this stuff about this agency doing- Oh, yeah, man. Okay, okay... undisclosed clippings. That's, that- I remember this... 26:38 it's been a big conversation the last few months in a lot of, you know, mainstream outlets, and that seemed to be one of the big reasons why. Um, but, and it was so controversial, right? 26:51 That people, that, that there's an agency contracting or, you know, paying accounts to post about this band and make their music popular, and this has been going on a lot longer. This had just- Oh, yeah... 27:04 happened to bubble up to this mainstream audience because of this band. I think that that kind of stuff probably has been happening for a decade. But the clipping, like, where it's kind of 27:15 been com- like super commercialized and super well-known, yeah, definitely it's becoming, past few years, like you see New York Times writing about it even, right? Yeah. 27:23 Even, even this week, I don't know if you saw the one about, I forget which prediction market it was, Polymarket was paying clippers to post about a fake website with fake winnings. That's crazy. That, like... 27:36 And no one is really doing anything about it, so I feel at some point there's probably gonna be either the platforms are gonna have to really police this stuff or some- the government's gonna have to step in or the FTC's gonna have to step in, right? 27:48 And, and really try to police this stuff better. But right now- And, and you, you-... it's Wild Wild West... you, you making sure that your stuff is always, you know- Oh, yeah... 27:56 disclosed is like a long-term play for the sustainability of your business to make sure this isn't some fly-by-night thing that gets shut down. 28:02 Yeah, man, I don't wanna see Culture Crave listed in some crazy lawsuit five years from now [laughs] you know? Like something like that or... Definitely not. No, that's 100%. Well, okay, so back to the ecosystem. 28:12 Is there anything we haven't covered? You, you told me how, you know, they, there, there's all these Discords and Telegrams and how the way it works is this assignment is put out. 28:21 People either go and the, either the content is provided or a brief is provided, and then- Mm-hmm... the links are delivered back and they're paid for that. One quick question on that too. 28:29 If the content is already provided, is that gonna be a lower CPM? It can vary, man. It varies on a lot of stuff. Like, if it's just... 28:38 The ones that I think I see the cheapest are is if you're just putting an artist's song and you're either- Yeah... 28:44 putting that behind a video edit that you make or something they make, those are usually really, really low CPMs generally because it's just, like it could even, doesn't even have to mention the artist. 28:55 It could just be the song is attached to the video, right? So those, those are generally pretty cheap campaigns. I, I don't see a lot of those over s- three CPM. Yeah. Most of them are one, 150, even less. Could be less. 29:10 Yeah. Like 50 cents. Crazy. But, oh, well, that's another good question. The, the broad price range. 29:15 Sounds like it can vary a lot, but if you had to give like, here's the, like describe an average campaign with the average CPM. What is that? Dollar, $1.50 probably. 29:25 In, in, in these true like Discord server clipping servers, dollar, $1.50. They'll, they'll gas up when they're putting a two. Like they'll alert you. They'll send you push notifications. Yeah. 29:38 Or they'll be like, "Yo, we're bumping up the CPM on this," because they can't get the people to buy in on the campaign, right? Yeah. So that's, that's a strategy on their end too for sure that works. 29:48 These guys, they're making a lot of money doing this stuff. Yeah. Um, but yeah, no, I think like that is... I have aspirations to do more, like, campaigns. 29:57 I, I wouldn't even call it just cl- I think clipping's one thing, and I would just say CPM campaigns. Doing these big campaigns. 30:02 CB- and you could say CPM campaigns where you're activating like a, a, a broad group of social media users. Exactly. Sophisticated s- people who are good at sort of earning and gaming attention on algorithmic platforms. 30:15 Exactly. And so like we're doing a small one this week, and we're gonna do some cool products. It's a Beavis and Butthead limited edition product, which is awesome. Yeah, it's like a brick set. 30:25 And we're also gonna do a Futurama one, and we're gonna do... I'm gonna probably do, like, I'm only doing it with two other networks, and we're gonna do, like, four CPM for these guys. And so that- Huh... 30:36 is, I think that's how I figure it out, is I start small with these campaigns, and then I can figure out, okay, is it possible eventually to scale? 30:44 And I need to test more of these networks, I think, too, some of these other guys that I'm talking to just to see if they're- Is this something, too, where, where the client has given you, like, "Here is the budget we have for this," and then you, you, you say, okay, to the, you know, to the creators, like, "We're doing a $4 CPM until this runs out," and that's this understood thing is that there's this specific budget and, like, strike now because this will be gone soon? 31:06 Exactly. It's more like, "Hey, we're doing a, this is gonna be a goal of a million views. We're not gonna pay over a million views. If you deliver, over-deliver, that's awesome, but, like, that's kind of, like, the cap." 31:15 Yeah. So, and I think that that is doable within, let's say if I'm doing Culture Crave and then I'm bringing in these networks and they're doing, like, one or two posts. 31:24 And I'm, and I know with these guys, for example, one of these Instagram pages is a huge page, and it's very active, and I love the way that they do their presentation, and I worked with them exactly on how we're gonna present this thing, and they, we pre-screened it each other, between each other. 31:38 I'm like, okay, I know that these guys, probably with two posts, are gonna get, like, 300,000 views. And I know with Culture Crave, I'm probably gonna get 300, 400,000 views. If I do two posts, probably more. 31:48 And then it's like, I don't actually really need a lot of other people then to just get that number. 31:52 And then if we, if it's, if it's converting really well, we have a deal with these guys that like, "Hey, let's do another million. 31:59 Let's see if we can get another million," and then they only pay the difference of, like, okay, if we get 400,000 views, then they'll pay that. That's kind of, like, how I'm thinking about operating it. 32:07 But some people will just come to you and be like, "Dude, we ha- we want 10 million views, and we have this budget. Like, what do you think's [chuckles] doable?" You know? And then they'll- Yeah... 32:14 probably also be going and pitching that to other Discord servers or other clipping servers, you know? 32:20 And, like- It sounds, too, like, like, in the way that you're bringing work to other networks, like other p- other networks and peers of yours are bringing work to you. Like, this is a very- Mm-hmm... 32:27 sort of collaborative ecosystem. It's interesting, yeah. Yeah, it's, it's can be very collaborative, for sure. Even- Yeah... um, definitely. Like, even, like, all the music companies, bro, are doing these... 32:37 And I'm not even working with many of the music companies, but they all do clipping, and, like, even I was even talking to an exec the other day who's like, "We're thinking about setting up our own." 32:45 [laughs] And I'm like, "You probably should, man. Then, you know, you have more control on all of it, for sure." Um, it's for sure. 32:49 Do you think that's the future of, like, of, like, companies having these in-house, and then does that hurt people like you and people like these, like, you know, just these other operators? 32:57 Does that, is that the future of this? Does this all just become so corporatized? I think that that will probably be part of it, that some of these big companies will wanna control it more to know... 33:12 And, and controlling it more, though, still makes, it removes that middleman, so if you're removing that middleman, you might actually be able to get more money as a creator to not have it go through that player who then owns the server- Yeah... 33:23 if you're just working directly with them. There's... I, I, I see it going that way, and then I still see, like, these big... There's still gonna be clipping servers and stuff two years from now, right? Yeah. 33:32 Unless literally the platforms start crunching down on this stuff and trying to eliminate it. But I don't know if they will because- I don't know that they would 'cause they make so much money... yeah, why would they? 33:40 They make so much money off it, right? But I think, like, maybe they're thinking, "Well, shit, we should be getting that money," if you're TikTok, right? 'Cause I don't know. We'll see, though. That, that's another... 33:50 We'll see. That'd be a fun one if you ever talk to someone at TikTok. You should bring up clipping and stuff to them and see what they're, like- Sure... 33:55 thinking about inside, 'cause that- Well, at least they're media trained. Yeah. [laughs] Probably. They're probably like... 34:00 [laughs] If you're building your whole video business on platforms like YouTube, here's the uncomfortable truth: They own the audience relationship, not you. That's where Open Video comes in. 34:10 It lets you host your videos on your own domain under your own brand, so you control the channel, the data, and the direct connection to your viewers. 34:17 And now, with the new Open Video MCP server, you could do even more without taking your focus off of your content. 34:23 With their MCP server, an AI agent can upload, tag, organize, and even analyze your entire video library from a single prompt. Your video stays yours, the busy work gets automated, and you can focus on creating. 34:36 Check out Open Video for all the details. That's open.video. You don't have to give me specific numbers if you don't want to, but I am curious about expenses and, like, how much the business is bringing in. 34:47 I'd say this because in that Indie Hustle interview I've mentioned earlier on this recording, you said that in 2023, your business cost around $5,000 to run each month and brought in between 20 to $40,000 per month. 34:59 Um, if you're comfortable talking about these numbers, I'd love to hear it, uh, but especially the expenses of running this business per month. 35:06 Yeah, so I think when I did that Indie one, they probably combined everything. So, like, even if it was consulting, Culture Crave, Latest in Space, all into one thing. 35:16 It's probably still around that number for expenses, but we've, for example, like, I'm not paying for all the features you do on Discord anymore. Discord costs a lot if you wanna have, like, every single feature, right? 35:28 So we paid- How much does it cost to the, your 27,000-person server? How much does that cost per month? I think it's, like, 100 bucks a month that we're spending right now, which is not bad. 35:37 But I think we paid more because I wanted to have where people could do all these other extra features and stuff. 35:42 Right now we do it where it's like, okay, we can do our cool emotes and profile pictures and the little, like, you can assign yourself a role. Like, you can be, like, Team Spidey. 35:50 Like, I love that stuff, and I wanna do more of that. 35:52 And then I, I should actually factor in, too, that I was working with a specific designer freelance guy who I haven't worked with in a bit, but we were having him make all that content 'cause we wanted to have a specific feel look, you know? 36:05 And so, um, right now, probably, like, 100, but it could be then I go back to this guy and be like, "Hey, we wanna do all this art," and then we just pay him, like, 1,000 bucks to do- Yeah... 36:14 a bunch of different designs or little emotes and stuff. 36:15 What, so if that's the $100 from, like, roughly, I don't need, like, a full accounting breakdown, but, like, roughly, where are these expenses going if it's roughly 5K? Mostly my designer. [laughs] That's most... 36:26 Yeah, and then- I would say, you know, like even t- you're on, well, you're on Beehive, so Beehive, that's like 150 a month to do, to host where we're hosting. 36:36 Even like with Twitter, we pay 200 for the verification to be in their kind of like their top thing. And then like with the other little sub-accounts that we have, those are like eight a month. 36:45 So like all of it kind of adds up. A lot of it is then subscriptions-based stuff. Photoshop, like we pay for Photoshop for the designers. SaaS fees. Yeah, SaaS fees. There you go. Easier way to put it. Yeah. Yeah. 36:56 A lot of it than SaaS, then designer, and then you do... To be honest with you, it's probably more than 5K, but like [laughs] that, that seems like a, a good number to say that- Yeah... 37:06 it's still probably around every month. Yeah. Uh, you're talking about the other accounts. Let's talk about that briefly. So you've got Latest in Space, which ha- I think you started that 2021. 37:15 It's, it's younger than Culture Crave. 37:17 Uh, it's got a larger audience by about 400K, 1.3 million views, but it gets a fraction of the engagement to Culture Crave, usually in the hundreds of likes, barely, rarely breaking a thousand, which to me makes sense because it's, you know, it's pictures of space, tele- telescope photos of nebulae. 37:33 Yeah. Nebul- nebulas, this kind of thing. It's not this like hyper current pop culture stuff that you're putting out on Culture Crave. Um, this is- It can be... one. Oh, it can be. 37:42 O- well, when there's like space related news, right? Yeah, exactly. 37:44 Uh, I guess my question here is can you just give us a little overview of your constellation of accounts besides Culture Crave, which we've been talking about this whole time? 37:55 Yeah, so Culture Crave, and then there's Latest in Space. Those are like the two, I would say, main ones for me. And then Culture Crave is on several other platforms. And then we have one called like Film Facts, which 38:07 pretty big Twitter page. I think it has like 300,000. And then we have also ones that are kind of like seasonal, like for example, Thrones Facts. It's not as active when there's not a show on, but right now 38:18 there's House of the Dragon, and then they're developing other shows, and then A Night's, Knight of the Seven Kingdoms was phenomenal and so like- Mm-hmm... I'm kind of obsessed. 38:25 I read those books too, so like I really like that story. I haven't read the books. I watched the show, though. Pretty fun. The show is good, man. That was my... 38:30 That, I think that's the fa- my favorite of their spinoffs so far. I mean, there's only two, but like that one I think like felt very much like how it was written, just kind of- I love a limited series as well... goofy. 38:39 Yeah, yeah. It's fun. And so like that one will come in. They have like a Marvel facts page. We have a Star Wars facts page. 38:45 So when I started Culture Crave, I actually started Culture Crave after I started these other ones. 38:50 So like I think the time, if I remember it correctly, I was just like obsessed with Game of Thrones, and I was kind of like, "Well, I'd love to do something in the pop culture world, so maybe I'll just do a Thrones facts, do that first." 39:02 And so we did that, and that blew up because Game of Thrones was huge at the time. 39:06 So I was really just riding kind of like the popularity at that point, and then using kind of like other pa- pages that I already built to kind of also boost the impressions on it and retweet it when it was like, "Oh, this has some viral potential." 39:18 And then from that we spun off Marvel facts, Star Wars facts, and at some point I was like, "Okay, I really think I should do an account that could just do anything, do all the interests, video games- Yeah... 39:28 and like dabble in all these things." And then so that's how Culture Crave came up. And then we'd grow Culture Crave through those basically. So Culture Crave was probably the fourth page I built. Okay. 39:38 And Star Wars facts, I'm looking at right now, has 144,000. Marvel facts has 213,000 followers on X. Yeah, they have decent following. They're more, you know, the, it's like I said with the whole, 39:50 they're more algorithmic these, at these point than- Yeah... people have notifications on for them, you know? And you post when there's relevant stuff to, to talk about. We do. 39:58 We just do kind of like evergreen content on a lot of them, and then treat Culture Crave as like this is the newsfeed now. And so- Yeah... if there's a Marvel news, we're gonna post it on Culture Crave. 40:08 If there's Star Wars news, we'll post it on Culture Crave, right? Yeah. 40:14 Do you have, do you have other accounts in the works, like things that you are planning to launch in the next year, or you kind of have the constellation you like? I'm, I'm more interested in maybe just buying accounts. 40:24 Like even with Latest in Space, that was one that I acquired. Oh. Like 10,000 followers. This dude named Aaron, he's awesome. 40:30 He still helps me run it as like a side thing for him where just our deal is like, "Hey, we just need to keep it active, like 30 to 60 posts. If news happens, then let's cover." 40:41 And he works, he works as a full-time writer at 9to5Mac. He's great. And he just was like, "Look, I don't really want this page anymore. Would you be interested in buying it?" [laughs] And I was like, "Are you sure? 40:51 Like, I love the page. Definitely I'd love to build it." And so I think I bought it when it had 10,000 followers, and we've scaled it since then. 40:59 And that's more what I'm interested in doing, I think, at this point is more like going and just buying ones that are either 41:07 like it feels like they're kind of giving up on the account and it's a great account and there's potential with it that it could work with in the entertainment network, movie and TV network. Mm-hmm. 41:17 Or, yeah, that's probably like where I'm more looking into is buying pages versus like, "Oh, let's go and start from scratch on something." 41:24 I think like what I'm interested in starting from scratch is like building Culture Crave in other places. So like TikTok eventually. 41:31 If I hire someone for Instagram, I might be like, "Hey, I want you to do TikTok and Instagram and see if that's possible." If I could find someone who fits in that. Yeah, you need different video talent for that. 41:39 Yeah, exactly. And then like video is more expensive, so that would probably even make my spend go from, I think it's like 5 to 7K a month to then like that's probably over 10,000. Big up front costs- Yeah, yeah... 41:48 if you can really get it rocking. Yeah, yeah. And that's a lot of work to put yourself on camera and do an edit on top of that and, you know. 41:57 I, I, it's, it's something I need to explore more though and think about, but yeah. It's a lot more work. Like I'm trying to keep it as lean as possible, right? 42:04 Like keep the margins good, not worry about going into debt, you know? And yeah, 'cause everything changes, man. 42:11 I, that's what I think about a lot with social media is stuff is constantly changing and like who knows, maybe Twitter just tanks. Yeah. 42:17 It's totally possible with this dude running it that it could just, they could just... 42:21 They're at one point, man, they were talking about turning off all engagement, so you won't even know how many likes or retweets and- I overheard that. Insane misunderstanding of the platform... 42:27 he still, he still posts about it. He still talks about it sometimes, and I'm like, "Dude, like if you did that, I mean, that's the dopamine. You're taking away all the dopamine- Yeah... 42:34 of what people want on that stuff, right?" So- Who knows, man? I mean, uh, something could die and something else could pop up, and then you have to pivot. I don't know. 42:42 So- That's, I mean, you know- I just, I think about that... that's why you're diversified to other platforms, that's why you have an email list, right? That's, that's- Exactly... 42:49 that's a- That's how we're- Obviously, uh- That's how we're trying to get our emails... Andrew might be here all the time. Um, a- Yeah... a question. 42:53 There's a GQ article from four years ago about your account, and then about Discussing Film, and about Film Updates. Oh, my God, I forgot about that one. Yeah. 43:00 I, I read it earlier, and what was really interesting to me about this was, I think Film Updates, they were fully anonymous. Discussing Film, um, was like you, like, you know, not really inserting himself into it, but 43:16 a- accessible. You, you're speaking with your, your full name on it, and even now it's pretty easy... It's, it's, it's easy to find that you're behind it. 43:22 If you're just, like, looking at Culture Crave on Twitter, you search or search who runs Culture Crave on Google, you're gonna come up. Why is the relationship between Zach and his accounts this way? 43:33 Why are you neither fully anonymous nor fully present, but you're just sort of this operator who is accessible and reachable? I think, like, it helps to have... 43:43 I mean, to help people reach out if they wanna work with you. I think, like- Yeah... 43:46 I get direct emails all the time, and I don't even know how they find my Culture Crave email, 'cause I don't think that one's necessarily publicized. 43:53 I'm assuming they're scraping that off of, like, Apollo or some- I f- no, I found it... it's out there somewhere. It, it was on, I think it's on one of these interviews. I think it might be... 44:00 I, I think it's at the end of one of those interviews. It might be my Culture Crave email. Okay, that's surprising. Yeah. I didn't realize that. 44:03 But yeah, no, I think just being accessible helps opportunities, and- It's because of your business model is why you're accessible. 44:09 Yeah, and I, and I think being open about this kinda stuff can help maybe someone else when they're trying to do this thing, right? So- Yeah... that's funny. 44:17 I didn't realize that Film Updates, 'cause I mean, I know those guys. I didn't realize that they were, like, being anon- I forgot about that article. They were- So if you look at that article- Yeah... 44:24 when they wrote that, that was old Culture Crave- It was November 2022... the first version. Yeah, that was before the relaunch. 44:30 So, like, if it says how many followers it has, that was right around when- You had 300-some K. Okay. Okay, that was definitely not then when we sold it [laughs] or when it, when we moved on and restarted. Okay. 44:40 But yeah, no, so that, that was old era, and that was when technically we were in talks to get acquired or, like, had a deal in place and figure, and we're figuring all that out. 44:51 But yeah, man, so I think just being open and accessible is super important, 'cause, like, I wish that there was people you could talk to you when I was first doing this stuff. 45:00 You really just had to kind of figure it out back then, and now it feels like- Yeah... there's a lot of people you could reach out to and get help with, and figure out a path for. And I, I think, like, helping people... 45:11 I've worked with people- Also, wait, wait. Let me-... and then they bring business back to you... let me correct myself. You, you had 751,900 according to this. I was wrong. Film Updates- Okay... 45:20 had 390,000, and then Discussing Film had 680,000. You were the largest at the time with 751,000. Yeah. Yeah, no, that sounds right. 45:29 Like, they were all behind us, and then we started again from zero, and then I, I don't know what they're at now. It's, I think Discussing Film is... Dude, they're great though. Like, I think they're a great account. 45:38 Yeah, so much. If I had to pick, you know, their- Well, tell me, tell me about them, like, how, how they are similar and different to what you do. Like, these, these people who are mentioned- Right... 45:46 in the same breath in this article. 45:48 I think, okay, if I had to compare, I would say Discussing Film is definitely, like, one, our biggest competitor, but they also cover more indie stuff, like more indie movies, and I think that we cover more video games. 46:00 We'll dabble in tech. They'll do comic books and stuff too. I think that we're more broad. Like, we'll cover a lot of different things. And, like, we can really hone in on a topic. 46:10 Like, for example, House of the Dragon, like, I'm gonna probably really cover that the next eight weeks. And then I'd say they're more broad. 46:16 Like, they might get, like, the bigger points, and then we might get into, like, the nitty-gritty of, like, what's the difference between the book, the books and the, and the shows and stuff, right? 46:24 So I think they're great though. Like, I, they're probably the only one that I would say that about maybe. I, no offense to the Film Update guys. I think they're more of kind of like... 46:33 Like, if you scroll Film Updates, it's a lot of pictures of you'll be like someone doing a photo shoot. Yeah. And to me, that's not really what we cover. 46:42 Like, we're trying to do more newsy and more kind of like what are the actors saying, and like what are the talent saying, and like the business of all of this too. I think we cover that. 46:51 And they definitely dabble in that. 46:52 But, like, I think if you looked at, like, their past day, their probably biggest post is probably a picture, for example, of the Obsession girl, indie, and, like, her just posing for some outlet, right? 47:03 Like, some images. And so I'd say they're different than us. And I, that's how I feel about even, like, with these other big ones too, like Pop Base and Pop Crave. Yeah. 47:11 Which is funny, because Pop Crave popped up the same time, bro, as Culture Crave. Like- [laughs]... it's so crazy to me that there's another one with the crave in it. Like, for me it was- Yeah... 47:20 I was trying to get the Culture handle, couldn't get it, so it was taken, and Twitter was impossible back then to, like, get handles. And I was just going, "Well," I was like, "I really like the word culture. 47:30 Let's just go with what could else could we do?" Culture Craze, Culture whatever, and then I landed on Culture Crave, 'cause it was a clean handle. 47:36 And then I see that, that, like, within a year, another one pops up, Pop Crave. 47:41 And they were called something else before, but I'm pretty sure they were probably right around the same, legitimately the same month or, like, the same quarter they probably had that name- Yeah... 47:49 or changed to that name. But yeah, no, we're not affiliated with them at all. I forget the guy's name, Will. I've worked with him on some stuff. But even then, I would say that they do... They're, like, really broad. 47:59 They might cover anything, which- When I think of Pop Crave, I think of, like, XYZ actor stuns in XYZ photo. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Stuns. Right? And that's their brand. 48:06 You know, like, that's, that's, that's- Which by the way, I'm scrolling Film Updates, and they're doing some of that. Film Updates right now, I'm just scrolling through. It's like, "This person attends this party." Yeah. 48:15 Um- Yeah... 48:16 Zendaya stuns at the Paris photo call for Spider-Man: Brand New Day, and then there's just a bunch of, like, this actor or, you know, other person has been invited to be a member of the Academy, and it's photo of them and photo of the Academy- That, that's news-... 48:28 of Arts and Sciences. Yeah. Yeah. That, that's, that's newsy. Like, we would do something like that, but, like, I wouldn't post that someone just stuns at a photo shoot. Uh, for one, like- That's not your style... 48:37 I don't think that... I mean, I don't, we don't pay for Getty or anything, so, like, everything we use image-wise, it's free of use. 48:43 It's Either a picture from a movie, a TV show, or like directly promo- sent out by the studios, or it's on a promotional website, right? Like, or the studio has sent us these images to use. 48:55 I do not even risk it with those because I know how that, how expensive that can be. I think one, one of their tricks is they do, is they do the quote tweet. 49:04 Like they'll post it on a burner page and it's like so clearly their burner page. So I, I feel like that's something at some point too, dude, that's gonna be- Yeah... people are gonna, people are gonna start realizing... 49:15 I don't, I mean, they must realize, but these people are gonna start- This is something that's being, that's very clear in this conversation is like you care a lot about operating in a legitimate way and avoiding any gray area operation. 49:25 At least with- That's, that's what you're saying... at least with the stuff, yes. Yes. Especially with things that I feel like are either established or like this is gonna get established soon. You know, I would say, 49:35 trying to think if there's any like real gray areas that we... I think maybe like video clips sometimes, like if you take a clip from a movie that just came out. But- Mm... 49:43 even, even with that or if it's like, "Hey, we're talking about this specific moment in this movie," and there may not be, 49:52 I don't know, like a, like an officially released image of that, but there is like an image online of it or something, we might not do that. 49:59 It, I mean, it sounds like maybe, I don't know if I'm gonna say more often than not, that might not be true. Yeah. But in some cases you are working with these studios to promote another movie of theirs already. 50:09 So it's this sort of almost like, you know, extra thing they get that they're not paying for you for, but they're paying you for other stuff. I'm generalizing and maybe- Yeah... putting words in your mouth. 50:18 I just, I just thought of a scenario actually too, leaks. Like sometimes- Mm... we'll cover leaks, but I will not like post the image anywhere on Culture Crave 'cause I know that's gonna get DMCA'd. 50:28 But I had an odd one the other day, man. This is actually kind of funny because I had to email NBC and be like, "Dude, this is ridiculous," but they DMCA'd, they put it on their NBC shop. 50:38 They posted a picture, like a set image from Robert Eggers' werewolf movie coming out. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And it was just like this like moody image, it was super cool moody image of just a bunch of trees and shit. 50:50 And it had his exact same feel that he has for all his movies. And so he posted the image as like, "Hey, this is like a first look thing." 50:56 And it was legit, but it was like on their NBC shop website and then the next day I get a DMCA notification. 51:02 The page is gone too, like the, the shop account is just like it's been invalid link now and I'm like, get a DM saying they're like, "Hey, this person illegally posted this image that wasn't officially released." 51:13 I'm like officially released? I wrote like a really professional email, but in my mind I'm like, "Dude, you're the one who posted it on your website, man." [laughs] Yeah. "This is officially out there. 51:22 Like I didn't take this from anywhere besides nbc.com." I included the hyperlink. Yeah. Like, "Hey, this is where it came from." 51:28 I saved a screenshot too of the website 'cause I was like, "Man, motherfuckers they tried to get me on that," you know? 51:34 And like, and getting DMCAs it used to be, I don't know if it is currently with a lot of socials, but it used to be that if you got DMCA'd a lot like they'd shut your account down. 51:43 I think they still do that on Instagram. I'm reading about- Yeah, I believe so... 51:47 I'll, I'll send you this stuff later, but I'm reading about all these film accounts and all these big meme pages that they're getting these false copyright claims and people are abusing the new 51:57 Instagram's AI system to get these accounts shut down and then sometimes what they'll even do is say, "Hey, I want a password reset," and they'll change the email somehow. 52:07 It's crazy man that this stuff is happening with... Like I'm two-step protected everything. Yeah. 52:12 Like Google auth codes, everything that you can to try to protect this stuff because people are out there- It's your livelihood... exploiting these things. Yeah. 52:20 And like it's, it, there is loopholes with AI and stuff and like integrating AI into everything and that's an entirely different discussion. Yeah. 52:27 Well, well- But I'll send you an article on that 'cause it's- Yeah, send me that... it's fascinating. So you had a Culture Crave podcast from 2019 to 2022- Yeah... and published roughly weekly about hour-long episodes. 52:38 You did 126 episodes over that three-year or so period. What was this and why did you shut it down? So I love that podcast and I, I get messaged about it all the time asking if we're gonna bring it back. 52:51 I probably will bring it back someday, but the biggest thing was that, man, we were like in that, and you were talking about it earlier just with views, we would get probably like 500 to 1,000 if I put it on YouTube and then combined between Spotify and Apple 53:06 we would get almost 10,000 an episode of people who downloaded it. But like to get into that 53:13 next tier of like where they'd pay decent rates for it you had to be consistently getting over 10,000 and we'd get a lot where it's like, oh, we get 5,000 after 30 days but then if like a big movie came out like that one we'd probably get 10,000. 53:27 Like Game of Thrones at the time when we launched it those were getting like 20,000 an episode and I was like, "Okay there's like something here," right? But I think what happened is it just was a lot of work. 53:36 Like I respect you- Yeah. For not-... so much- For no money... to do this. 53:39 For no money and like we, yeah, I would make enough that I would be able to pay my friends to, and my, and my editor and my video editor to make this stuff but I was like damn I'm putting three, four hours in to listen back to this and I was doing the same thing you're doing man like we would do these very just open conversation every time and a lot of times too it'd be like end of day if I was with my buddies man we'd be smoking weed too like we would just [laughs] it'd be very it'd be very loose but it was like- A loose conversation. 54:08 Yeah. 54:08 [laughs] Very loose you know but it was like we I, I was very knowledge- like we were all very knowledgeable on the stuff we were talking about and I'd send them briefs too same way where it's like hey here's kind of like what we're gonna talk about and it would just be about the topics from that week but as you're going through you know it's it's definitely more loose and so there'd be way more editing I'd have to do 'cause there'd be points where like you just even forget what you're talking about sometimes right? 54:28 You get get on these crazy tangents and I'd be like well this is a fun tangent but it's not on topic for the podcast so. For, for the listener let me just shout out- Yeah... Tom who edits every podcast episode. Yeah. 54:38 Shout out Tom man. He makes it sound way smarter. 54:39 [laughs] Shout out Tom bro but because that was that was what happened with it and then what happened too is why it stopped was just during the transition of- Okay, are we selling this? 54:50 Is this gonna be sold or am I getting it back? And then I haven't brought it back. And then, like, my two friends, I love them. One has a kid now, so he's so busy. 54:58 My other buddy lives in New York, um, up in the Bronx, and we talk about it all the time, but he wants to do... He wants in on the... He's helping with Pop Culture News too. Mm. Where he's gonna be... 55:07 'Cause he, he used to be with me too when we were at Rolling Stone. He would write. 55:11 He's one of my guys, 'cause I needed someone who was in America as well as, like, the Australia stuff, 'cause I was just like- Time zone, so... "Dude, if something happens, we need someone for news here," right? 55:19 So we're gonna probably do that, and then, like, if... I'm thinking about using popculturenews.com to then try to fund that again. 55:26 But for me, if someone came and was like, "Yeah, we'll do an ad program with you guys, and it'll be a pretty decent one," I'd be open to doing it again. I love podcasting. I mean- Yeah... I think it's fun. 55:36 It's just, like, it's a lot of work, you know, on top of- Yeah... everything and on top of pitching, on top of... 55:42 Like, right now we're working on two or three pitches for really interesting projects, and it's like the time it even takes to make examples and put together the decks and stuff, right? Yeah. Like, all that is time. 55:53 And but, like, that actually usually leads m- back to money in the pocket. That wasn't leading to anything. It was a, it was mostly for fun, because I just couldn't figure out how to get over 10,000. 56:03 If I, if I spent a lot more money and did clipping and did all that stuff- Yeah... 'cause we were doing our own clipping back then. 56:08 Like, we would do full edits where, like, I'd put the audio and then we'd edit a video explaining that over it, and those did really well. 56:15 But that's even more money you have to spend on it, and I was never breaking even on that thing unfortunately. Nice one. I love podcasting though, dude. It's fun. Has it been fun? Well, I got one more question for you. 56:25 Uh, uh, sort of a rapid fire two-hitter. Um- For sure. In... You've been working in social, you know, earning attention for over a decade now. 56:34 What do you see in the current meta game that is on its way out, and one thing that is on its way in? 56:41 Besides, we've talked a lot about clipping, but what in the meta, w- something around growth methods, content styles, or monetization, what is on its way out of the meta? 56:49 What is on its way into the meta over the next year or two? 56:51 I think, I think I touched on it earlier, but I think out of the meta is just, dude, if your entire social strategy is just to only post your article link on your social, you need to be rethinking that completely. 57:02 You need to be thinking about content that lives on these platforms, 'cause that's what all the platforms want. Or you'd be thinking about how do you present that article in a way... 57:11 Uh, even like Variety, for example, is doing a lot better at this. Like, they'll- Mm... do their article, and then they will drop that link two or three times under. 57:19 And, like, that's a great way to do it, because you're just still getting little extra clicks you're probably never gonna get doing that. So I think if legitimately your whole feed is just, "Oh, we're gonna put this... 57:28 We're gonna use the social media tool to put it on autopilot and just literally take the subtext and make that the headline and post it on social," that's dead. I don't think anyone's gonna click your content anymore. 57:41 And if you are getting clicks now, you're not gonna get clicks in two years because your following is just gonna get less and less engaged. 57:47 And the content, the platforms are just not gonna recommend that at some point, if it's not dead already, I mean. But, like, we're talking about, for example, Blue Sky. 57:55 For, if you look at, if you look at our engagement, which isn't insane or anything, but it's pretty good for Blue Sky. 58:01 You look at, like, the way that we do it, even with the linking, like I can say via THR, and like I have this tool now that I can highlight via Hollywood Reporter, and you can click that and then send it back. 58:11 But those probably get even less clicks than doing the reply, because I don't think people even realize you can click that. And then, but if- Yeah... but it gets a lot of engagement. 58:19 That post will get really good engagement. But if, like, CNN on there, they have 600,000 followers. 58:24 I'll look at our comparison and, like, we get better engagement than them because most of their content is clearly just they've set up a bot to post over to mirror their posts to Bl- And nobody wants that... to Blue Sky. 58:35 You know when- And so you click, like, you know, millions of followers with like three likes per post [laughs]. Exactly. Exactly. And like, like why, why is that your, still your strategy at this day and age? 58:42 I mean, you're CNN, man. Like, you have the budget. 58:45 You know, you should be thinking about if you're really gonna invest in something like Blue Sky, you could probably take over Blue Sky if you're CNN, if you really locked in and did that stuff, right? Mm-hmm. For sure. 58:54 Like if you really thought about a different strategy and how you're gonna build, 'cause they're doing that on TikTok. They convert all their articles into videos. Pretty sure. They're doing that on Instagram. 59:05 They're doing it on all these platforms. But, like, the text-based ones, it's like why are people forgetting about that? Because it still could be a great traffic source for you. 59:12 So that, I think, is probably, probably the biggest one. And then the other one is probably if you, like, you don't source at all, and you just take someone's entire content. Mm. 59:23 You're not even mentioning where you got it. I think platforms are gonna really start cracking down on that because of just the free- Instagram already has. They're, they've, they cracked down on aggregators, right? 59:32 If you're not posting a bunch of original content, you get demerited in the algorithm, I believe. That's interesting. It would be interesting too if they could be more, even more specific. 59:39 Like how many, how much original content versus even if you're, like, a news aggregator, like what do you want? How much do you want? Do you want every post to be original? 59:49 Do you want someone to take the news and make it into, like, a graphic headline? Like is that technically original content? I don't know. 59:55 I guess, like, still the, what a lot of these platforms probably need to do is specify, but that's, that... I did see the CEO. He even said that recently again, right? That they were gonna crack- Yeah... down further. 1:00:04 Yeah. Yeah. I'm seeing this post- I think it's-... from April 30th from, on the Instagram creator's account. He p- he posts on Threads a lot about what they're doing- Hm, Instagram... at Meta. Yeah. Yeah. 1:00:14 So that's probably the other thing is, like, you just need to... 1:00:17 There's still a lot of different niches and a lot of things out there that you could still go into, but right, like you said, like original content I hope will become king. 1:00:26 Hopefully not AI content, but [laughs] like actual real human content. 1:00:31 I think that that is a, this is my hot take, but I feel like there is opportunities for social media platforms to eventually pop up where it's completely human content, and it's like no AI is allowed, and they somehow- Yeah... 1:00:44 are able to verify that. I don't know how you do that without... Like, you cannot do it in a way where, like, you're giving up, like, your bio, whatever. 1:00:51 Like you have to, like, poke a thing and, like, give them your fingerprint- Oh, yeah... or some shit. We don't want that. No, yeah. No one's gonna do that either, right? 1:00:56 So like, but I think there's an opportunity there on social media to do something where it's, like, verified humans somehow, and it's, you're, in a way that, like, this information isn't being sold at all or anything. 1:01:07 But, like, I think that that is also a trend that I could see happening in the, in the next few years. It's interesting. You see a lot of pushback for AI stuff these days, and- Yeah... corps don't get it. 1:01:18 Like, they still wanna keep pushing it, and it's like, man, you're gonna lose, you're gonna lose business at some point, man, 'cause of this, 'cause of the, these mandates you wanna do, I think. But I don't know. 1:01:27 That's another whole other discussion. I'd love to- That's another conversation... get to that sometime, but it's a conversation for another time. We'll, we'll, yeah. We'll end this one right here. 1:01:34 Zach, thank you for coming on. Listener, we'll see you next time. Thank you for having me, man. Had a good time. Yeah. Cheers. 1:01:40 [outro music]