Transcript 0:00 Newsletters are very difficult to grow, and if you're building it for a reason of clout because you think it's gonna be a moneymaker, you're gonna run into terrible, terrible failure. How big is it now, the list? 0:12 So the list right now is twelve thousand. We've grown completely organically. What are some of the things that did and did not work? The best way to grow anything is to do it consistently. 0:21 In fact, I haven't done anything as consistent as my newsletter in, in, in my life. My goal for it has always been build something bigger than myself. 0:30 Do you know how many people have shown up to your events, like lifetime unique attendees to all your events? Eight thousand and thirty-three people have RSVP'd to- Wow... one of our events. And that was always the goal. 0:41 I just wanted to meet people. Welcome back to the Creator Spotlight podcast. 0:47 My name is Francis Zurer, and today we're speaking with Brett Dashefsky, the creator of Creator Economy NYC, a newsletter and event series based here in New York. 0:56 We spoke about how to build and monetize a healthy community, how to develop long-term brand partnerships, how to produce events and the kind of money that goes into them, and his advice for making high-quality newsletters, which he has been in the business of for about six years. 1:10 So this is a really good conversation, and I think you will enjoy it. I wanna set the stage here for our listeners before we even get to Creator Economy NYC. Um, you are the second Dashefsky to come on this podcast. 1:26 Your brother Jared was on here, um, what- Is this okay to wear, by the way? You can wear that. Yeah, you can wear it. Okay. 1:32 Well, I think, you know, you know, I'll s- this is, this is a little, um, you know, behind the curtain for the listener. 1:37 I think if you say certain words early on in the video, then maybe they, um, YouTube will ding you in the algorithm. So we won't [chuckles] say the words on your hat- Okay... for a little bit, but we'll get there. 1:47 Anyways, you're the second Dashefsky to come on here. 1:49 I interviewed your brother, like, a year and a half ago, and you and him work together, so you have a few, like, chapters of your experience with the Creator Economy, and I wanna not, like, spend a long time on them, but I wanna get through this a little bit. 2:00 So six years ago, you join your brother Jared to work on Healthcare Huddle, right? Wow, yeah. And this was a newsletter business. Yeah. And that's kind of your entrée into the Creator Economy, correct? That's correct. 2:14 So what, like, what were the challenges you were dealing with? 2:17 Because this, for, very quickly for the listener, like, this is a, as you might guess by the name, it's a healthcare-focused newsletter for healthcare professionals. 2:24 You are not a healthcare professional, um, but your brother is kind of the creator, and you are helping him with audience development and monetization, right? Mm-hmm. 2:33 So tell me what those challenges were that, like, in these early days six years ago- Mm-hmm... beginning of twenty twenty, you are helping him build this newsletter-based business. What are you dealing with? 2:42 Yeah, I mean, well, first and foremost, the biggest challenge was we were using MailChimp. [laughs] Um, just, just to, to put that out there. Mm-hmm. 2:49 But yeah, I mean, look, the idea-- my brother had this idea, uh, as he was starting medical school, and I was in my senior year of college, and I've always been very entrepreneurial and social native, interested in social media, and, uh, was toying with some ideas myself. 3:02 And he had this really great idea that I thought would be super cool to build a brand around. Like, I love brand building, um, obviously, you know, see the hat and, and what I've been building. 3:11 [laughs] And, uh, I saw an opportunity to help him, like, grow this on social media. Let's, let's create an Instagram page and build that into something that is, is value driven and perhaps serves the newsletter. 3:24 And I, I didn't have any healthcare experience at all. Uh, in fact, that I felt like was a big challenge for me mentally being like, "I'm not really in this space. 3:33 I just happen to have created a media business-" Mm-hmm... uh, that, that focuses on this content." 3:37 But I learned a lot actually through the content, funny enough, and the whole ethos of what we were building was to simplify complex issues in healthcare. 3:44 Um, and so, you know, some of the challenges as we were growing was ultimately, like, what is this thing and, and what can it be? And we were building at a really exciting time when, um, Morning Brew- Mm-hmm... 3:58 uh, I think it was about we were a year into building Healthcare Huddle. Morning Brew was, like, our biggest, um, inspiration. Yeah. 4:04 And I, I'm a longtime Morning Brew reader, and, like, we studied everything that Alex and Austin did to grow that thing, and we're applying as much as we can logically to growing Healthcare Huddle, be it a campus ambassador program, be it how they did sponsorships, things like that. 4:19 And, um, you know, I think the big challenge was, was ultimately monetizing the newsletter and growing it. 4:26 There at the time were no, you know, discoverability vehicles for newsletters like we have today with Beehiiv or other platforms with referrals. And so you had to grow by way of just being scrappy. 4:39 And, uh, some of the things that we did was, like, every time someone followed our Instagram, which was our big top of funnel- Mm... we would message them to subscribe to the newsletter. Uh- This is before ManyChat too. 4:48 You were doing the same- This is before ManyChat. Yeah. Like, like everything that creators have at their disposal today did not really exist or was as popular in twenty twenty. 4:56 And so timeframe, this was twenty twenty, twenty twenty-one, early twenty twenty-one. Mm-hmm. And, um, so we were growing through the newsletter. 5:03 We were using the Instagram stories, and, like, at the time on Instagram, not everyone on stories could link something. You had to hit, like, ten K followers in order to be able to link anything on stories. 5:14 And so what we would do was basically we would use the question sticker and be like, uh, promote the newsletter, and then be like, "If you wanna subscribe to the newsletter, like, write your news-- write your email here." 5:24 And then, like, we would manually take the emails and then put them into MailChimp. Or I think, like, I would, I would add them manually on the website because then they would be sent the welcome email. 5:34 And so there was a lot of challenges because we were very, um-- there wasn't the tech there to support what we were trying to build from a media standpoint. 5:41 And fortunately, m-my brother's classmate, Harrison, was our CTO, and, like, he built out, like, a custom website. He connected, uh, whatever to, you know, Google Sheets to MailChimp. 5:51 And, like, we had systems in place, but there was a reason there wasn't a ton of newsletters at the time. And podcasts. Most writers actually were on, like, Medium. Mm-hmm. Or, or, or they were on... 6:01 Substack was just getting started. I don't even know. Um, or they were using, right, a con- uh, um, a, a MailChimp or something like that. 6:10 And so, um, that was kinda the challenges we, we led into, but-We were building a brand that, uh, was punching above its weight- Mm-hmm... 6:18 which has always been like a, a value of mine when building a company, is create a great brand from the way it's presented, that it feels like it's punching above its weight. It, it looks more established than it is. 6:29 And that drove a lot of interest to our Instagram. It, it ended up driving people looking at our newsletter as a credible source of information, which, like, you know, we obviously made sure that that was the case. 6:39 Um, and then it led to us ultimately getting acqui-hired by, by Workweek when they were building for this next era of the creator economy of this collective of, like, industry experts. And who was that industry expert? 6:52 It was my brother. Yeah. And what was I gonna do at Workweek? Well, come help and maybe grow some other newsletters and, and creator brands, which was- Well, so-... so exciting for me... uh, so I wanna butt in for a sec. 7:00 So Adam Ryan, co-founder of Workweek, another former guest of the pod, if, if you're listening and you wanna check that out. 7:05 Uh, but I understand that there you kind of stop working on, like, the one project, the one product, and your... 7:12 I think your title is creator manager, and now you're helping a bunch of other, uh, you know, category experts. 7:17 This Workweek also, to be clear for the listeners, basically, I'm sure Adam would, you know, dispute this slightly, but it's basically, like, a network of creator-led newsletters and professional networks. 7:27 And so you're helping these other category experts launch and grow their audience, kind of taking the learnings you had with your brother and now, like, scaling them across other creators. That's correct. Um, 7:40 so th- yes, at the time, and that still is kind of the focus of Workweek, but my, the enticing element of joining Workweek and leaving my job at Capital One- Mm-hmm... right? 7:54 So I was building Healthcare Huddle alongside a full-time job, was I didn't wanna become pigeonholed in being a h- a healthcare guy. Hmm. Okay? And I saw this opportunity with, with these leading voices, right? 8:07 And, and this is when Twitter was really big. You had people like Truong Fan and Nick Sharma that were all, like, part of now Workweek. Mm-hmm. 8:13 And I was like, "Wow, if I can, like, go and associate myselves with this grouping of, of creators, it's, it's going to help me grow my personal brand in this space." 8:23 And so I took that leap to join Workweek, which was not even launched yet, m- with the bet that it was gonna help me leap onto a higher mountain. Mm-hmm. And then that's ultimately how I think about opportunities. 8:34 And I would say that, like, it absolutely was me leaping to a higher mountain because it led me into the direction that I, like, was, felt my gut was the best, uh, was the best path. 8:44 And, you know, despite me ultimately, you know, leaving the company, um, n- you know, not on, not on my own terms, it still put me in the best possible position. Mm-hmm. 8:54 And I learned so much helping build other brands, and I learned so much from Adam and Becca and the rest of the team there that now as I'm building Creator Economy NYC and even SIFSC, I just feel like a much more, um, experienced founder. 9:08 Yeah. And I know how to build a media business, and I, and I've been doing it. And I also think that- Well, okay, well, that's, that's what I wanna focus on. 9:14 I wanna know, like, some of what did and didn't work when you were at Workweek, like, helping these other creators grow, right? 9:20 Like, I know from Adam that a lot of the growth came from, like, the network effect of, like, you know, each-- You, you bring somebody in, they've already got some audience. 9:28 You're, you're kind of funneling that audience to some of the other creators. That makes sense. What are... 9:32 You know, for the listeners looking to, to grow, what are some of the things that did and did not work when you were working there, like, across categories? That's a good question. Um, we definitely grew... 9:43 So for example, like, yes, I, I, I stepped away from Healthcare Huddle day to day, but Healthcare Huddle kept growing because we had a really strong paid media strategy, and so we did put a lot of paid growth behind the newsletters to grow- Mm-hmm... 9:55 which is popular, um, and was necessary at the time just because there wasn't that many, again, that, those discoverability and growth vehicles. 10:05 Um, so I think that worked, but, um, I don't wanna speak on, like, what went wrong or right there. Mm-hmm. But I, I do think that maybe there's some elements of 10:14 the paid, and then we like, we would funnel people into, like... The whole idea was like, can we connect a lot of the brands together to an extent? 10:21 And, you know, sometimes if you would subscribe for the healthcare newsletter, it might also, like, ask if you wanted to opt in for, like, the healthcare newsletter, and so, like, a HR newsletter and then healthcare newsletter. 10:30 And so maybe you started to get, like, audiences that were commingled that maybe shouldn't have been commingled. Um, so I think that, like, that was a challenge, and I think just in general, um, 10:39 you know, the working with talent, it was a really interesting experience 'cause, um, you know, you need to keep them on deadlines, and, and Workweek was selling really well, which was really- Mm-hmm... 10:48 exciting 'cause, like, we, we weren't really selling much at Healthcare Huddle. And, you know, you have to, like, have these creators make sure they're hitting their deliverables and getting the things out there. 10:57 And I think what was interesting about having creators be identified as creators and being seen as talent, right? They were seen as talent. They weren't seen as, like, a journalist, as an, like, an employee journalist. 11:06 Yeah. So hitting deadlines was sometimes a little bit loose, right? "Oh, I'm, I, I'm busy today. I'm gonna get it, like, sending my newsletter out tomorrow, to, like, this tonight." 11:15 And it's like, "No, no, no, but we had, like, a sponsor spot that in-" We've signed a contract. Right- Mm-hmm... for the morning. 11:20 And I think that that's just what a lot of people deal with when working with creators in general, right? 11:25 B- for example, like, I, I am, I am privy to that, if, you know, that's the right word, where, you know, I was supposed to get an ad out for, um, a, a storefront, uh, you know, SaaS company, and I was like, "Hey, can we push this to next week? 11:40 Like, I'm just not gonna... I, I'm just so behind." [laughs] And th-that, like, they're accepting of that, no problem. But, like, when you're dealing with, like, multiple newsletters- Mm-hmm... 11:49 or a lot of money and, like, it's a complex system with different pieces of talent, that became a challenge. 11:54 Um, and so I definitely learned and became, uh, very empathetic of how a creator operates and, and, and navigates and then also, like, what it takes to operate as a creator. 12:04 And, and I've ultimately, I took a lot of those learnings to turn into a creator and, and business owner myself and media owner myself, uh, and understanding that element. Hi there. 12:13 My name's Tom, and I'm the producer here on Creator Spotlight. I'm just interrupting this episode really quick to ask you to subscribe to the channel if you haven't already. We're coming up for 4,000 subscribers. 12:23 It's coming up to the end of the year, so if you watch this channel regularly or you get any kind of value from it and you haven't hit subscribed on YouTube yet-We'd love it if you could do that and get us to that 4,000 subscribers before 2026. 12:37 We love those round numbers and those milestones, so if you could help us out with that, it'd be much appreciated. Back to the episode with Brett. Uh, I'll now [laughs] allow you to talk about your own media business. 12:46 So Creator Economy NYC, I understand it primarily as two, maybe three things, maybe two and a half. So there's the newsletter, which is what... how I first discovered it. 12:56 Um, I think I got on there, you'd only sent maybe 10 or 17, um, it was r- it was shortly before I started doing Creator Spotlight. And then there's also this events business. 13:05 And then kind of on top of that, it's like a production, almost agency partner, I would say, for brands. Production partner is maybe a more accurate word, and that's, you know, to do with the events business. 13:16 Um, tell me about how this comes about. Uh, first, what I understand is that you were no longer at Workweek, and I think shortly after that you started a contract role at Kickstarter, head of creators. 13:27 I want to learn more about that a little later. 13:29 Um, but then you maybe launched like this Twitter group and slowly this idea of, like, you just wanting to meet other people in the creator economy industry in New York turns into this, like, series of events and then a newsletter. 13:45 So I... That's what I've got. Tell me how Creator Economy NYC comes to be. Yeah, Creator Economy NYC came out of my just desire to want to build something of my own. Mm-hmm. 13:57 Where Healthcare Huddle was something of my own, um, but, you know, I had other co-founders and, uh, it, it wasn't initially my idea, right? 14:05 So I kind of like helped grow it and, and, and, you know, led the direction there. 14:09 But I wanted to create something of my own, and I was so inspired by all the creators I was working with at Workweek that I too wanted to be a creator myself. 14:17 And so funny enough, I actually started a LinkedIn account called Creatorology, which still exists, and I was sharing a lot of tips and insights for creators f-from that account. 14:29 And I was trying to basically create like the Marketing Millennials, but- Mm-hmm... geared towards creators, which kind of is what Creator Economy NYC ended up becoming. 14:36 Um, anyway, I had to stop posting from there for a variety of reasons, um, but ultimately, I was really intrigued by this element of, of, like, doing something in real life, primarily after I was invited to a creator economy happy hour in February of 2022. 14:58 And, um, you know, at the time, like the word creator economy was still very, m-m-you know, minimally used. It was emerging. Yeah. And I was like it w- I was like, "Of course I'm gonna go to this." 15:07 And I met so many operators in the space, Josh Kaplan of Smooth Media. Um, there were some people there that still come to my events today. 15:16 Uh, there was a lot of people there that were doing podcasts, you know, over COVID, and I was like, "This is so exciting to like bring what we've been talking about online in real life." 15:24 And, um, I wanted to like build community around this, and so Twitter launched this thing called, like, Communities, and, um, I just like toyed with the idea of creating something called Creator... 15:35 I think it was Creator Economy Meetup NYC. And I loved branding, so like I just threw around an idea of like taking the subway and making it that. Yeah. 15:43 And I thought this could be like a unique place to just connect, and that was always the goal. I just wanted to meet people. I had no ulterior motive. 15:50 Um, but then I started to see this guy in the healthcare space that was building a, a, like an events business, hosting something happy hours and stuff, and I was really intrigued by that model and also inspired from the happy hour I went to, that ultimately I was like, "Okay, I just moved to New York." 16:05 This was November of 2022, alm- you know, almost about three, four years ago. And, uh, I told myself, "Okay, starting in January, I'm gonna just host a bar meetup," just like- Mm-hmm... 16:17 I went to back in February, and, um, I'm gonna call it what it, like the Twitter thing was because that's where I first posted, "Hey, I'm hosting this thing." 16:24 I think I remember writing in there, like, "Would you guys come too?" And I'm like, "Whatever. I'm just gonna do it anyway. Fuck it. Create it." Um- [laughs] And, uh, 16:33 ultimately, I chose a bar, and, um, I knew from working with creators at Workweek that the best way to grow anything is to do it consistently. Mm-hmm. And so I said, "What's a feasible cadence for me?" 16:44 And the feasible cadence for me that I considered consistent, right? It's not every day. It's not every week. It was once a month I would host a meetup. 16:52 A- And I told myself it, it's, it just needs to be very low, uh, you know, cost and, and no cost at all. You're just picking a place and you're, you're organizing that. So I chose this bar in the Lower East Side. 17:03 Terrorist- Put out a blast. Think about 40 people RSVP'd, which was really cool. Think about 15 or so showed up, many who still come to our events today. 17:12 And I continued with that on a month-to-month basis, and I was communicating with these people by way of BCC. I was BCC'ing them on email after being like, "Hey, great to see you. 17:23 You know, hopefully the next one will be next week." And i- in there I'd always say, like, "If anyone wants to be able to host us or sponsor, let me know." 17:29 And started to get people being like, "Hey, I can host you in our office. I can... You know, we'd be happy to put $500 towards this." I'm like, "Whoa, okay." And I started to just lean into that. 17:36 And, um, that, that really was the nature of Creator Economy NYC. And again, the idea was just for me to meet people. Mm-hmm. I, I was not making a dime from this and had no intention. 17:45 I had no idea actually how to monetize it. And then through feedback, someone was like, "You should start doing like fireside chats or whatever." 17:52 And that's ultimately what led to me doing a fireside chat with New York City creator Tim Chiezano, who was like blowing up at the time. And then the next one was like a, a panel. 18:01 And now, you know, our events are always a panel and mixer event and, um, it started to really take shape and gain traction, and we've partnered with brands like Beehiiv, like Pinterest, like Shopify, Teachable, Notion, right? 18:13 All of these massive great companies and, and Creator Economy NYC has genuinely turned into like a profitable media and events business- Mm-hmm... 18:21 that is serving creators, marketers, and, and, and the, you know, platforms that are, are, are serving this space. Um, and, and yeah, that's what came to be today. 18:31 And so just through consistencyAnd through, uh, a genuine desire to meet and build relationships in this space is what led for it to be. And I have learned through it that community is incredibly difficult. Mm-hmm. 18:44 You have to want it. You, you need to build community knowing that, like, this thing probably won't make money, and, like, would you still be doing it if it wasn't making money? 18:54 And to me- Here's what you should ask yourself, right, with a community. It's like are you... Do you host parties? 18:57 When you are hosting a party, are you good at, like, you know, swinging around from person to person making the connections? 19:02 Like, I think, I don't know, but correct me if I'm wrong, but I feel like that's, like, the atomic unit of, like, can I build a community, right? It's like can I... 19:11 At a party, am I connecting people and being like, "Oh, you should meet this person. Oh, wait, hold on, I gotta go talk to this person. You should meet them." I consider myself to be a, 19:20 and based on feedback by the way as well, a fantastic host. Mm-hmm. A lover of people. A, a great host and MC when it comes to- I've seen you in action... analyzing. See me in action. Um, and I love doing it. Yeah. 19:33 And, and for the love of the game. And, um, that is what led me to keep building this thing, and I've seen similar organizations pop up in different cities, which is great. 19:42 Um, I've heard from them that, you know, we've inspired that model. But I know how difficult it is to grow the thing. Mm. 19:48 And if you're building it for the set- for a reason of clout, if you're building it because you think it's gonna be a money maker, you're gonna run into terrible, terrible failure. Um, because- Okay. Wait, wait, wait. 19:59 I, I wa- I wanna get back on the events in a second, but before we get off fully newsletters, right? I wanna talk about the newsletter aspect- Oh, yeah... of, of Creator Economy NYC. 20:07 So, um, that's how I first came about it. Um, if you're comfortable, are you willing to share list size, open rate, and or click rate? Yeah. You don't have to if you don't want to. No, happy to. 20:18 Little backstory on the newsletter if that's cool to sh- to go share. Give, give me the backstory. Well, a hundred sends, by the way, you hit very recently on those big- I did. Yeah... queries. 20:25 It's a very timely episode. Mm-hmm. Um, sorry. I got... I get very excited about community- [laughs]... 20:29 which the newsletter is, by the way, an essential part of the community, and one of the biggest anxieties I had when building the initial days of Creator Economy NYC was losing consistent contact- Hmm... 20:40 with the folks that were showing up to the events. 20:43 And so if I didn't have an event scheduled for the following month, I worried that if I went, like, a whole nother six, seven weeks without even communicating and showing that we're here, we would lose this element of that we exist. 20:53 And so I... That's why I was on BCC. Mm. And the reason I was on BCC is because, one, there weren't really platforms like Beehiiv that were there. 21:00 Two, I was kind of treading carefully that I wasn't being competitive with Work Week and, like, launching a brand in a category that maybe they were exploring. Um, but heading into 2024, 21:14 um, I really was feeling this need of, okay, if this thing is serious, I should launch a newsletter, and the idea was to launch the newsletter in January of 2024. So, hey, we just went through this year hosting events. 21:24 Now the next thing we're gonna launch once we have the events down is gonna be the newsletter. I ended up getting laid off from Work Week, 21:30 and that to me was one of those, like, it's go time stories where you hear so much about people who were laid off or fired from a job, and it ended up being the best thing to happen to them. And I basically told myself, 21:42 "Well, I, I wanna be one of those stories." Yeah. 21:44 I want to, I want- I've talked to so many people, by the way, especially journalists, who it's like they got laid off, maybe they got a little bit of a severance package, and then, like, that severance package is basically startup capital for them trying- Yep... 21:53 to build an independent media business. 100%. Um, and that ultimately was the mindset I had. And so where's the first place I went? It was Beehiiv. Actually, when did I start my Beehiiv account? September of 2023. 22:08 Um, the first newsletter was sent on December 14th or so, I believe, of 2024. Mm. Uh, sorry, of 2023. Yeah. That was, uh, new... 22:16 I think we sent three or two or three newsletters in, in that year, and then, uh, I'll get into another aspect there. 22:22 But I remember after getting laid off from Work Week, my first, you know, order of business was I was gonna go through all the event RSVPs and data I had, clean it up, and then upload it into- That's a list, baby... 22:33 um, Beehiiv, and I locked in. I was so excited- Mm... and I was so passionate that the newsletter was gonna be the biggest thing for Creator Economy NYC and myself, which it truly has been. 22:43 And I was so excited that, wow, here am I starting my own newsletter brand, right? It's me. It's, it's no one else involved in this. And, um, I spent... 22:54 Like, I was working more than I was working when at Work Week, like late nights, had to be pulled away from the computer, cleaning up the data from the events, figuring out what my newsletter was gonna be about and h- and how to approach it, what the branding and all of it should look like. 23:07 And, um, we, we rocketed it. And then heading into 2024, back to the consistency goal, I go, "Well, I set a consistency goal for events, and that worked out pretty well. I gotta do the same for the newsletter." 23:18 And I created this chart with 52 empty orange circles, and I made a goal that I would send one newsletter a week in 2024, and I did not want a week to go by where I did not fill that circle in. Okay. Wait, wait, wait. 23:31 Did you... Every time you sent it, would you go to, like, Canva or whatever you're using and- That's correct... and fill it out? [laughs] That's nice. And I kept it on a Twitter thread. Yeah. 23:39 So you could see the Twitter thread of all the weeks I was up- updating the newsletter. And it started to really inspire people to follow along, and also for other people to be like, "I wanna do the same thing." 23:51 And, um, I, I felt that this element of building in public or, or- Mm-hmm... public accountability to send this newsletter once a week is what really locked me in. And at this point it's become, like, routine. 24:03 In fact, I haven't done anything as consistent as my newsletter in, in, in my life. [laughs] You know? E- except maybe wake up and go to the bathroom in the morning. 24:13 [laughs] Um, and, uh, that was just so huge because now I had another community element with, uh, the events. Mm-hmm. 24:21 And that people who subscribe, who came to the events or RSVP'd were now on the newsletter, and then they were immersed in the community. 24:26 The genesis of the newsletter is to create a place for people who are going to the events to keep track of the events. It's basically as simple as that. 24:33 But then it becomes this other thing of, like, this driving force for you. And th- there's good editorial in there too. Like, you recently had, um, one that was like a taxonomy of, like, types of creators. Yeah. 24:43 You had another one, like, what's the difference between creator and an influencer? I love these topics. Yep. Um, but so that's the genesis. How big is it now?... the list? So the list right now is 12,000, um- Damn... 24:54 subscribers. We've grown completely organically, uh, primarily through our events is the number one driver of subscribers, and then the second driver is, um, the, uh, Beehive referral network- Mm-hmm... 25:07 which has been so powerful. And the key to that has been ultimately having refer- referees who, uh, are aligned with, uh, what your newsletter is about and what their newsletter is about. Yeah. 25:19 And so I have, um, like Jack Appleby's newsletter, Future Social, has been a huge driver to my newsletter. Um, Brandon Smith Rick's Content to Commas has been a huge driver to my newsletter. 25:29 And so- Frequent- uh, friends of yours and frequent, uh, attendees of Creator Economy NYC events as well. That, that's correct. Yeah. 25:33 They, they've been, you know, integral, uh, a- and great friends, um, that I met only through Creator Economy NYC. The open rate is at 56%. 25:42 Um, so it's remained a very leaned in and intentional, uh, newsletter for people. 25:47 And, um, you know, I think there's an element of the in real life aspect and being able to connect with me and the community makes people feel excited and passionate about the newsletter. Yeah. 25:55 And it's also a place where you go and get up to date on the next event. Yeah. That was almost the original intention of the newsletter. It was just a place for you to see what's upcoming. 26:03 Um, and now as we just hit newsletter 100, I'm genuinely thinking about more ways to better editorialize the newsletter and turn it into something that can maybe even scale beyond me, um, because I, I do see Creator Economy NYC continuing to serve not only creators but marketers, the influencer marketing, creator marketing space. 26:21 Well, wait, okay. Uh, oh, yeah, that's interesting. So you, you said that, like, when we first started talking too, that maybe you're separating Brett and Creator Economy NYC a little bit. 26:28 Um, and I'm curious how you pulled it off. What you just said, like, made me think, of course, of Colin and Samir and how they have The Published Press. Uh, but that's, you know, the- it's... 26:36 They, I think, own it, but they don't write it. It says, like, edited by them at the bottom, but it's, I think, uh- Right... Hannah and Sid are the two journalists- That's correct... who, who write it. 26:46 And so, like, it sounds like you aspire to have something like that. Yeah. So w- w- when I, when Creator Economy NYC started to become more and more of, like, what I viewed as, like, a, a, an actual brand and a business, 27:00 m- my goal for it has always been build something bigger than myself. And for, you know, for a long time I've been leaning into, like, my, you know, I'm the face of Creator Economy NYC, that Brett is Creator Economy NYC. 27:12 But, like, as I'm growing it and, and think about what do I wanna do longer term, you know, I, I don't... I think that Creator Economy NYC can thrive beyond me being the core face of it. Yeah. 27:22 We go back to the Dave Portnoy example. 27:24 And that, yes, I could probably move into more, like, an editor-in-chief role of the newsletter and have someone who may be more tapped in doing more editorial, be it creator exclusives, like what you do. 27:35 Um, you know, I, I don't think that that needs to be me. Um, I enjoy, like, being a face of the business and operating the business, but I don't know if I need to be in the weeds of everything. 27:44 I, I love being the talent and showing up and moderating and hosting. 27:47 So, like, I'm really trying to hone in on, like, what do I like to do and what don't I really feel like I need to do, and how can I delegate that properly? And a big thing for that also was, like, content. Like- Yeah... 27:56 I don't need to be doing video content on Creator Economy NYC's Instagram. I can actually probably find some talent to, to do that. Well, what about, uh, sh- what is it called? 28:04 The Signal, formerly Creator Economy NYC TV. Oh, see, yeah, yeah, yeah. So I was doing that, but I- This is, by the way, for the listener, this is, like, a short-form video series. 28:11 He's done like four or five of them- Four or five, yeah... over the past couple months. Yeah, they're, they're pretty funny. And it was like, like Stephen Colbert news but for, um, the social media world. You've got... 28:20 I mean, well, well, an example of one, I think this is the last one you've done, and it seems like you kind of maybe have stopped doing them. I don't know. You can tell me that in a second. 28:26 But the last one, it's like you're this newscaster, and then you're calling in correspondents such as Frat Brett. That's correct. They're just you dressed up and with an accent. It's quite funny. 28:34 But the last one's like Frat Brett. Like, the story you're covering is that, I think it's Syracu- Syracuse, um, University in New York, uh, they recently launched a, like, creator business program. 28:45 And this is something that was covered in a lot of other newsletters, for example. I think I read about it as well in The Published Press. Yep. 28:50 Um, and you're just covering it, but, like, with this, like, entertainment angle of, like, you know, you're putting on the Frat Brett persona and, like, you're, you're giving details about it, but, like, in a very joking manner. 29:01 Yeah. Yeah. And, and that was really fun to do, and I feel like that could be, like, my segment. Mm-hmm. 29:06 Um, but frankly, honestly, from a time standpoint, I'm like, I just do not have the time and energy to put into this. Did... Was that just you producing that? Like, you made the graphics and everything? 29:13 That was just me producing it. Yeah. Yep. Um, and, uh, yeah, I, I just had to be honest with myself in terms of, like, is this a hell yes right now? Um- Yeah... what else might, uh, require your attention? Mm-hmm. 29:25 And, uh, I, I do s- foresee it coming back. Uh, I just need the dust to settle in terms of a lot that I'm just laying the foundation for- Yeah... heading into 2026. Okay. 29:34 One, one more thing on newsletters before we move off of newsletters fully. So again, you for four years, basically, you worked with your brother on Healthcare Huddle. 29:42 Um, you were at, uh, Work Week for a couple of years. That's, you know, newsletters, and you've been doing this now for two years as well. So a lot of newslettering experience. 29:50 Um, I wonder if you have any advice you would give to the listener beyond, like, the basic, like, obviously, as your hat says, fuck it, create it. Just do it every week consistently for 100 plus weeks. 30:00 That's, like, the classics. But, um, I think with you specifically, anything around, like, the editorial approach, the design, you're big on that- Yep... and audience development. 30:09 Any advice you would give our, our listener who is not the novice but, you know- Yep... a little above that? Well, if you're just starting out in the newsletter world, like, don't overthink it. 30:18 And if you were to, like, look at my newsletter and what I'm doing today, remember that I'm 100 newsletters in, and that's 100, you know, newsletters of iteration. Mm-hmm. 30:26 Uh, and so maybe look at what I was doing in the beginning, uh, so you can kind of feel, uh, in terms of, of just, like, the, the practical element, or look at someone who recently started, um, ahead of you, uh, you know, just recently. 30:41 Mm-hmm. And, uh, don't overthink the design to start, um, and don't overthink the editorial. That's rich coming from you. 30:47 It, it is, and I, I, it, it, I, it hurts me to say that, but I just don't want people getting caught up inThe design of their newsletter before they even fully understand perhaps what it is they'll be writing about and how, how the newsletter is. 31:01 And for me, you know, my newsletter has certainly evolved in terms of like how, what I write about. 31:06 Like, I used to do creator spotlights, and then it moved to me kind of sharing more from the community and, like, my own personal experience growing as a creator, um, and, and business owner. 31:15 And, uh, if you get too caught up into the design, it might pigeonhole you to be writing about a certain thing or a certain way, um, where first you kinda wanna get the editorial element down or how you wanna be communicating with your audience. 31:27 So that is something I think is really important, is just like don't overthink it. Like, uh, you know, perfection is the enemy of progress. 31:32 You don't want that to stifle you from just getting your newsletter out there, and you also, like, need to get in the element of building the reps. Mm-hmm. 31:38 And so anything that's gonna prevent you from building the reps of getting your newsletter out there, you gotta put it on the back burner. 31:44 And so, like, for me, like, building out the, the newsletter, I knew, I was like, "Okay, I have to get this out next week, uh, this December. I, I, it doesn't matter. 31:53 Um, stop overthinking the design or what you're doing. Just get it out." And, um, that to me, I knew when I would do it would be a huge unlock because it would show that mentally, like, it's already out there. 32:02 You got the engine revving. Now you gotta keep it going and iterate as you go. And it, it, it should give you comfort in knowing that, like, people are goldfish. 32:09 They're not gonna remember what your newsletter looked like last week versus this week, and if they do, fantastic. You got a great, you know, uh, reader who's leaned in. 32:16 Um, so that's what I say is hugely important, and don't overthink growth. Mm. Newsletters are very difficult to grow. Um, they're long and arduous to grow. 32:27 And, um, you have to almost be in the position where you are writing the newsletter for the sake of yourself and for the sake of, of, of just the accomplishment and passion- The sake of filling out 52 of those orange circles- Yes... 32:40 if you will. You know, that might help for some people. It helped me, for sure. But just start writing your newsletter and creating it for the love of writing. 32:47 I mean, I loved my newsletter and still love it, that it's just a creative outlet for me. Um, and, and, uh, I don't even really pay attention to what the open rates are or who opened it. 32:57 [laughs] I actually don't think in all 100 newsletters have I really, like, clicked in and, like, viewed that in one- Well, you know, when your numbers are good too, you don't really have to worry... I guess so. 33:05 Yeah, yeah, you know. I, I don't... Like, do you look at your thing? Um- [laughs] But I wanna get better at that, right, so I can serve the, the, the readers better. But 33:14 I would just, like, feel accomplished when I got it out, and I'm like- Mm-hmm... I don't even care if it's just my mom reading it. I don't even care if my mom's not reading it and no one's reading it. 33:23 I have the accomplishment that I pieced that together. Um, and if it happens to strike someone in a positive way, fantastic. But I'm just, I just love the fact that I like, I, you, you can get this product out- Yeah... 33:33 weekly and get, like, immediate feedback from it, and, like, that's very unique in the world of media, where you can get that immediate feedback and iterate. 33:40 And, like, I love that, like, my next edition next Friday can be completely different, and I have no rules to follow. Yeah. That's the beauty of, of working for yourself, right? You have no rules to follow. Yeah. 33:49 And that, that's what always has guided me to entrepreneurship, and especially the world of the newsletter. I love that I can change the logo next week. Mm-hmm. Okay. It's my creative direction. 33:57 Speaking of working for yourself, can you tell me all the different ways in which you are making money at this point in time? Yep. 34:04 So, um, right now with Creator Economy NYC, and again, um, this is excluding other businesses- Mm... um, the events and the partnerships there are our main revenue driver. 34:12 I would say probably upwards of almost, like, 90%. Um, then there's revenue that has come, um, by way of the newsletter, which I do kind of loop in with, uh- Mm... the, the events. 34:24 Um, and then we've made, um, some money through, like, some educational products. 34:28 I recently launched a course conveniently called Fuck It, Create It, which is literally all about what we're talking about, you know- Mm... getting your ideas out there, taking that bold action. 34:35 Um, that sold a, a handful. 34:37 But events have been our, a main driver, and when I say events, I mean kind of packaging that with, uh, you know, hey, a newsletter ad is included in that sponsorship fee and maybe, like, a post on LinkedIn. 34:51 Um, so, uh, the goal heading into 2026 is that, uh, we can monetize every single newsletter, um, somewhat in, independent of an event. Hmm. 35:02 Uh, and that, you know, would be phenomenal if we get to the point where maybe there's so much inventory that we have to launch a second newsletter, and what would that look like? 35:09 But I'd say brand partnerships have been almost 100% of, of the revenue for Creator Economy NYC, um- And it sounds like you want that to continue to be the case. 35:19 You just want more types of sponsor- of partnership- Yeah... available for advertisers to purchase. In 2026, uh, as I'm... 35:27 Which is actually funny, just doing some OKRs, the goal is that 90% of revenue is coming from events and brand partnerships. Mm-hmm. Which is inclusive of the newsletter, our Instagram, whatever it might be. 35:38 Well, which is also, you just told me that that's, it's about 90% right now. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. So the goal is to- So to maintain that... continue with that. Yeah, yeah. What's the other 10%? 35:46 Um, uh, education- Education is the other 10... and maybe affiliate revenue. Um, so we wanna lean maybe more into some educational stuff. 35:53 But my goal as I'm juggling a lot is just, like, I really wanna maintain continuous focus. Um, can we nail down and hit those goals and grow the newsletter? C- Can we start to build Creator Economy NYC beyond Brett? 36:06 Mm-hmm. Uh, I think is going to be a big 2026 goal, and, uh, a big element is also operationalizing the, the brand, um, so that there are more systems and processes in place that enable it to scale- Mm-hmm... 36:18 and that we can do more. Mm-hmm. Um, okay. Speaking of monetizing events, I went to my first Creator Economy NYC event about- It's great to have you... thank you, two or three weeks ago as we record. 36:28 Um, and you said this there when you were up on the, the stage. Um, there wasn't a stage, but when you were up in front of everybody, you, you said, you know, "This isn't really a typical Creator Economy NYC event." 36:38 This is really... It was a Teachable launch event, a launch event for their rebrand, that you were kind of like a host partner. Like, to me, the way I saw you, I was like, they're... It seemed like they're paying you... 36:49 You can tell me all the things they're paying you for, but it seemed like they're paying you primarily as, like, an event promoter, right?You know, that's an interesting way to put it. 36:57 So, um, I engaged in 2024- in tw- this year, uh, with a year-long brand deal, brand partnership deal with Teachable, um, which, you know, you wanna talk about? I absolutely do. 37:07 What part- Putting the, the- Okay Well, I was gonna say, if you wanna talk about the effort of, of compounding, right? Like, that was a huge outcome- Yeah... that was, like, really cool. 37:13 And I- I've written a bunch about, um, you know, how that came to be and what that looks like. But, so the thing with Teachable is typically the way that, like, our events work is that, um, there's two sponsorship tiers. 37:22 Basically, a brand is, um, a, basically like a presenting partner- Mm-hmm... which would be, like, Creator Economy NYC x Beehive. Yeah. 37:28 And then maybe there's some supporting partners that are additional brands, like Teachable Which, to be clear for the listener, by the way, uh, we're not paying Brett for this episode. Uh, Beehive is not. No, you're not. 37:36 But Beehive has paid him in the past. Yes, and I hope they pay me more- [laughs]... because with all this latest announcements, there's big, big synergies. 37:44 Um, so the way that Teachable usually works is like, yeah, so like I- I... We would, like, align on, like, a panel topic if you're a presenting partner, right? 37:51 You get k- kind of editorial control, and we wanna do something that talks about something geared towards your brand. 37:55 Um, but this one was unique because Teachable was doing a rebrand, and, um, we already had, like, an event slotted per our agreement. Yeah. 38:03 And they're like, "Let's just, you know, leverage you and the community to do this." And I think, like, another big thing that was interesting here is that, you know, if Teachable was just hosting a Teachable event, 38:13 w- it... Who wants to go to just a Teachable event, right? But when you kind of pair it with a native community, there's that leaned-in element that people already have this, like, authentic connection. Mm-hmm. 38:23 And that was, uh, Teachable and I, we, we ho- Teachable and Creator Economy NYC hosted a conference together back in May called CONNECT. Mm-hmm. And the same, it was the same thing. 38:31 Teachable mainly handled a lot of the logistics and things like that. That was c- this was that on a smaller level. 38:36 Uh, we did also put up some money though, just to be clear, 'cause we had money from the partnership that needed- Mm... to go towards this. Um, 38:43 but yes, it did kind of operate where it's like, "We want to leverage you and your community, your, the NIL of it, to promote the event." Yeah. And it still was our event to an extent. Like, we know our team was there. 38:53 But there is that thing where it's like, oh, this is a Creator Economy NYC event, as opposed to this is a blank, you know, platform event. Yeah. 39:01 And- Well, well, tell, tell me, tell me more about, like, the specific, like, deliverables for them. I will say that, like, you know, I was there. Brendan Smitherick was there. He was making content. I went up to him. 39:10 He's like, "What's up? I'm making content for this event right now." And then, you know, I saw at least two other people going around with cameras and mics, I think. Somebody doing interviews, somebody probably- Yep... 39:19 just taking photographs. Um, so there's, there's clearly, like, content being produced at and about the event for later distribution was one of the deliverables. What are the deliverables- Yep... for an event like this? 39:30 So if you saw Brendan creating content, he was doing that for Teachable. Mm. 'Cause Teachable had some of their own... Like, it was very- Oh, yeah... like incestuous. There was some other brand partnerships going on. 39:40 Um, and then the other people doing interviews were my team. Yeah. So we're leaning into more content, right, uh, from our events. 39:47 So the way those part- those partnerships look like, typically, if you're a presenting partner, like Beehive's been a presenting partner before, what they get out of that and the deliverables I provide are, you know, of course, hosting the event. 39:56 Um, when it comes for the panel, right, like, like curating that panel, um, in partnership with, with the brand. Mm. Um, their name is, is, you know, next to ours on all the graphics and mentioned in the newsletter. 40:08 Uh, and then, you know, they get access to the RSVPs, some lead gen from there. Um, and so it, it's fairly simple, right? 40:14 And, and so, like, when I think about Beehive partnering with us, it's like, look, if Beehive was just hosting their own event in the city, I'm sure they would have some success, but then, like, it's Beehive hosting it, and so- Yeah... 40:24 look, they're probably, there is an element there where it's like they're probably trying to sell something, blah, blah, blah. But when you partner with- That's always, that's always a given with any brand event... 40:31 It's always a given, right? Yeah. And people kind of come in with that mindset, whereas if you do an event with Creator Economy NYC, th- there's this, "Oh, I'm going to that Creator Economy NYC event. 40:39 Oh, I think it's, like, Beehive's a sponsor." Bl- So I just think there's this more organic approach- Yeah... where, "Hey, we're not trying to sell you anything." No. 40:46 "We're just here working with our partners that are serving this community." 40:47 What's on offer is just, is like, you know, open bar and some snacks and, uh, some other people who you can make connections with to, you know, make money with in, in your own job. [laughs] Exactly. 40:58 A- and a big thing from it that Beehive would get, uh, just using Beehive as an example- Mm... is content. So, like, you know, they can talk about the event. They can show up with some collateral, maybe hats- Yeah... 41:06 maybe stickers, and look, just develop good vibes with the event. Mm. Do, do events lead to direct conversions that you can trace? 41:13 Um, I would say no, but through enough repetitiveness, you start to see people really have your brand top of mind because they have positive associations with it. 41:23 And- Well, th- this, this is, this is something that, like, um, whether it's, you know, 41:27 uh, like more just brand partnerships, not just at events, I think, like, that's one of the jobs of a creator is to, like, educate that, like, yeah, you might not be able to, like, measure the specific thing, like, you know, this kind of obsession with a, what, what do you call it? 41:38 Like, last click attribution, right? Like, part of the point of this is, like, is, is brand building. It, it's, it's... A creator partnership is rarely... 41:46 Like, if, if you're a marketer going into it and you're just l- purely looking for, like, dollar in, dollar out, like, that's, that's not really what this as a marketing channel should be. Exactly. 41:58 And, um, that's how we basically talk about it. A- and that's why also, though, pairing it with a newsletter or something else is super powerful because it, it opens up that opportunity for more direct- Mm... 42:08 attribution. But look, if, if... Like Teachable, we've been partnering all year. 42:12 Someone came up to us at the event and was talking about how he's a talent manag- uh, talent manager, and he launched, um, some courses on Teachable for his creators. And it's like, that's... 42:21 Like, these are the stories that, like, it just comes with time. Yeah. 42:25 Especially when you're, someone's launching a newsletter, when they're launching a course or something, like, these are things that, like, it's not just, like, an immediate sign-up. 42:31 Like, they need to be intentional about it. 42:33 And so the big thing I would talk to, like, Catherine at Beehive about, hi, Catherine, is, you know, look, you're, you're just building these positive associations top of mind with, with the community. 42:41 Um, what I do wanna ask, uh, is, like, for the creator looking to set up a long-term brand partnership, right? I wanna, like, I wanna learn from you how that comes to be. 42:50 I do know you've said this in another podcast, that I think it was a moment in Q4 2024, I think, when you signed this long-term deal with Teachable, and that's kind of like theMajor inflection point of Creator Economy NYC as a business that, like, sets you up for any success that you are currently experiencing, right? 43:07 Um, so how do you, like... Like, if you are beginning an engagement with a brand, I'm sure that first with Teachable it was, like, one or, like, a one-off or, you know, "Here's a couple deliverables I'm gonna give you." 43:19 How do you turn that into, like, "Here's a long-term partnership that is, like, a secure source of income for me for the next year that will sustain me"? How do you get to that point? How do you, how do you- Right... 43:30 convince a marketer, [laughs] a brand to do that with you? Give me your budget. Yeah. Um, well, it, it, it comes with time. So I'll use Teachable as an example here. 43:41 We first partnered in, um, literally right after I got laid off from Work Week in November- Mm... of 2023 to do an event together, and I think they paid, like, $2,000. It all went straight to the event, right? 43:54 I made nothing on it. And then we didn't partner again together until June. Mm-hmm. And then we didn't actually partner again until heading into that September. 44:02 So there was a lot of sporadic partnerships and relationship building, um, that led to, "Is this something we could engage with long term," um, and to, like, stop doing this, like, one-off type of thing. 44:14 And so we initially did, like, a quarter-long partnership in Q4 of 2024 that then as we were heading into the new year, we talked about, well, we should, you know, I'm pretty sure Teachable wanted it, right, and so did I, but, like, can we do a year-long thing together? 44:27 And, you know, that was exhausting thinking through. I really had to put my media sales cap on- Mm... which was crazy. 44:32 I, I, I, I'm honestly proud of myself for how I did it, but, like, I was like, "Oh, shit, I have to get, like, into, like, an events calendar and, like, inventory calendar, like, what's gonna go towards what." 44:41 Um, and I've had a lot of learnings from this year. 44:44 But the way that that works is ultimately you're probably gonna need to start and show the value that you can provide and, like, is this, is this a, a, a partnership that's worth building out. 44:53 Um, and then also, you know, continue to showcase the value that you can provide to them. And so, you know, what are Teachable's goals, right? Mm. What, what are X brand's goals? 45:01 How can I be the medium that's enabling you to do that? 45:04 And it's funny 'cause my brother with Healthcare Huddle is actually working on that right now with a couple of brands in terms of how to do something long term, and none of these brands are new necessarily. 45:12 They've worked with him before. So for, for creators and, and, and any media operators that are looking to do long-term stuff- Mm... 45:18 right, you, you often probably will need to engage, um, I think most times in working together previously, but a lot of it comes down to relationship building. Yeah. 45:28 Um, I spent a lot of time with the Teachable team in 2024. We were at South by Southwest together and spent all time there, which I do believe led to us then partnering in June, then we did an event together in June. 45:40 We did an event together at VidCon in June, so we were hanging out together again. 45:44 Um, I went to VidSummit and hung out with, um, Olivia, who leads creator partnerships there, and we just, like, we're building a, a nice relationship. And at the end of the day, like, sales is all relationship. 45:55 It, it, you know, you, you m- maybe there is a better avenue for them to go, but they wanna go with me and Brett- Yeah... and Creator Economy NYC. 46:02 And so you have to, like, put the effort into building those relationships and showing up, um, which then might, you know, ultimately convert hopefully into something long term. Yeah. And this is your whole thing. 46:11 This is your whole thing. Like, this is what the Creator Economy NYC is too, is it's about building relationships with the people in the community. 46:17 It's about, like, creating a space where other people can build relationships, right? Like- Yeah... 46:20 I w- I, when I first became aware of you too, I was like, "I don't think this guy's really a creator," you know, 'cause I'm always looking for people to maybe have on the podcast, and I thought, "This guy isn't really a creator. 46:29 I think he's a marketer." 46:30 And now, now that I've gotten to know you a little bit and I've, like, been to one of your events, it's like, to me, what you are is, like, you do kind of have some of all of, like, the three skills of, of media, of being a creator, right? 46:41 Which is, like, producing content, um, audience development, and, and monetization, right? Like, you have a talent for all these things, um, but at the core, like, I do see you as this, like, this organizer, right? 46:55 You're a relationships guy. 46:56 Every business is a relationships business, you know, as, as the saying goes, but, like, that's the business that you specifically are in more than other people, both, like, you know, to brands, to audience, and, like, facilitating that for both parties, right? 47:09 Yeah, I think that's fair. A-and something I've grappled with personally is what is that identity that I possess. [laughs] Yeah. Am I a creator? Am I a founder? 47:17 I would say that when I wake up in the morning, I consider myself, um, a founder. Mm-hmm. I wake up with a founder's mindset. 47:23 I, I prefer to be recognized as a founder, and I think I'm a creator by way of just, like, documenting my journey of building and also, um, uh, just sharing my takes on the industry. Mm-hmm. 47:34 Um, but at the same time, someone would say, "No, you're absolutely a creator because you are, you're just like an in real life creator. Like you-" Yeah... 47:42 you are doing what so many digital creators would love to be able to do, and, like, that's your, your specialty that you own, that you can fill a room through this brand you've built, and you can also go up on stage and perform." 47:53 And so am I a performer? Am, am, am I, am I a professional public speaker, right? So these, these are things that I still grapple with, like what is that identity. I don't get too tied up in all that. No. 48:03 But, um, I would say, look, I write a newsletter. I, I've written a newsletter more consistently than, than I would maybe say most people ever have. And so that to me makes me identify I am a creator. This is- Mm... 48:14 this is, this is my... I might not have a huge following on Instagram, but, like, I have- It's not how, it's not the size of the audience, it's how many, it's, it's who's in it, right? Like, I mean- Exactly... 48:22 that's how you make money. Um, so I would say that, uh, I would consider myself to be a founder and creator, uh- Yeah... if I, someone, you know, had to, had to ask. Uh, a-and an organizer for sure. Yeah. 48:31 I mean, I, like, like- So I, I, I don't wanna get too pedantic here w- 'cause I have a bad habit of doing this, um- Yeah... on this podcast in real life, but I, I'm curious- Who am I? What was that? 48:40 You ever see Zoolander and he's like, "Who am I?" [laughs] You know, that's me. I'm looking into the spoon- Yeah. [laughs]... and that's what I'm doing. That's me constantly. In a puddle of man. 48:47 Um, I have a constant midlife crisis, um, you know, early maybe for a midlife crisis. I hope it's not my midlife. Yeah. But anyway, neither here nor there. 48:53 Um, I am curious though, like, how you define creator economy, in a specif- not, like, to me, who knows enough about it, but I mean, like, you're, you know, home visiting your parents and there's, like, a family friend over there who doesn't really know anything about this. 49:05 How do you... You're like, "I work in the creator economy." What is that? How do you tell them? 49:10 [laughs] Well, first I would define the creator economy is, um, essentially, uh, individuals who are making a living by way of, um, digital content on the internet- Mm... to an extent, right? 49:26 Um, and that could be a number of mediums or ways in terms of how they're doing that. Oh. Uh, so you're asking like how do I describe, like, what do I do to someone? 49:33 Yeah, to somebody who doesn't work in this industry at all. Right. Well, I think the simplest way is I would say, like, I am, like, a, a, I, I run an, a media and events company- Mm... 49:41 that, uh, brings together this digital economy, so people who are creating content, uh, people who are, are maybe, like, um, uh, using those people, those creators as a way of marketing, and then also the, the folks that are maybe building the platforms that support the monetization of this space. 50:00 And I think the economy is a really important word in what we're building because it's not just about con- creators. Yeah. It's not just about creating content. We genuinely tout this element of, like, how... 50:11 The business of creators is the, I think is the best way to describe Creator Economy NYC, and we have thought leadership around that. Yeah. 50:17 And it's funny, like, the initial model I had in my mind for Creator Economy NYC was, like, the economic club of, like, New York or something. It was, like, this, like, nonprofit thought leadership place, right? 50:28 And I was like, "Okay, great." Like, well, I just wanna create that. 50:31 I just wanna create a space where people in the industry can come together and just, like, have open and free conversation around topics that are shaping the s- the industry. Um, so yeah. 50:40 So I would consider what I do like a media and events business and what, who we serve are the people that are basically creating content online and are ultimately, you know, building a business- Mm-hmm... from that. 50:52 Do you know how many people have shown up to your events, like, lifetime unique attendees to all your events? Um, I know this past year, 'cause we just did an analysis on it, it was, like, 3,500 or 3,600-plus. 51:03 Uh, I, I, RSVP'd rather. Yeah. Uh, 'cause w- we get upwards of anywhere between, like, 500 and 1,000 RSVPs per an event. Um- And 100 people come or what? I would say around, uh, it depends. 51:15 Actually, i- in the past venue we had, uh, upwards of 200 come. So we accept enough people and curate it well enough that it ends up being around 200 people. Yeah. 51:25 Um, actually I do, uh, properly have actually a number here. Oh, yeah. So on Luma, uh, 8,033 people have RSVP'd to- Wow... one of our events. Powerful. I'm sure that number's in the media kit. Yeah. 51:40 So it's, it's, it's there and, you know, the newsletter's great, uh, 'cause all those people are subscribed or some have unsubscribed, no problem. Um, but still really strong. Yeah. 51:48 And so it's a lot of people and it's, it's a diverse grouping of people. And so that's- It's... 51:52 I mean, it's, it's kind of, I think you've said on another podcast, it is kind of an even split of creators, marketers, and service providers. What's the split? Yeah, I would s- it's majority creators I would say. Mm. 52:02 Okay. So upwards of, you know, 50, 60% creators, and then the other bunch is, uh, marketers and, and brands and, and operators in the space. Um, and it's a wide range of creators, right? 52:10 Because it's not just full-time creators, but it's some part-time creators, it's, it's emerging creators. 52:15 And I wanna curate that environment because I think there's something that, like, uh, a full-time creator can learn from a part-time creator, uh, because they might be monetizing in a different way, or they might- Mm... 52:24 be using YouTube and the other creators are mainly on Instagram, right? And I have creators who I see as, like, full-time successful 500k-plus followers that want to know how to do a newsletter, right? 52:35 And they look at me as an, as an expert on that. Yeah. And so our, our main flagship events, the ones like you went to, are more, um, I would say, uh, diverse, uh, but still curated, right? 52:45 You have to be accepted into the event. And, and that's just to create the experience and also for the sponsors, um, or partners rather. And then we have some dinners that maybe are more intimate and targeted. Mm-hmm. 52:55 People who are full-time creators, people who are, you know, focused on finance, content, stuff like that. Are there people... 53:00 I mean, I'm sure, like, not counting the dinners, these more, like, intimate events, are there people who have shown up to every single one? 53:06 Or I'm sure nobody has shown up to every single one, so, like, you know, functionally every single event. Um, I would say yes. 53:13 Uh, and it's so great because, like, at this last event, right, there are people that I remember being there at that first event. Um- Mm... and it's just, it's just awesome that, like, they've seen this grow. Yeah. 53:23 They, they feel, like, emotionally invested. And, um, it's funny, I'm working on a project right now to be able to go and track that data. 53:30 Who RSVP'd to an event, who actually showed up, and then, like, to be able to identify those, those key fans. Um- How are you, how are you doing that? 53:37 Is this, like, something you're using, like, you know, put all these people in Claude and say, "Hey, figure this out"? Yeah. How are you doing that? 53:43 So I recently hired, like, a fractional COO who's assisting with this stuff, but Luma, I have all that data. Mm. Because when you subscribe to the events you have to fill out basically, like, a survey, right? 53:52 This is how I get this first-party data on people. And then when you come to the event, uh, or you're accepted and you have to check in, so then Luma has that data. So Luma on each individual event has all this data. 54:02 Yeah. 54:03 And i- it's just not standardized because I've changed the questions, and I, I beat myself up because every time after an event I would upload all the data to Beehiiv, but I s- I got lazy and started, like, cutting out fields. 54:15 Mm-hmm. And I'm like, "I'll come back to that later," and here I am being like, "Okay, here's later. Now you gotta go and do this all manually." Has Luma ever paid you any money by the way? 54:22 The way you're talking about them, it sounds like they should. I- Luma has never paid me a dime. Um, they, I, I, they are the greatest platform, so essential to my business. I, I, you know, 54:32 everyone should be using them and I should be on the pro plan. Don't say that yet. Don't say that yet. Yeah. Wait till they pay you. [laughs] Um, but, uh, Beehiiv, Luma- Yeah... that would be sick. Yeah. 54:41 Um, one, one last question about events. You don't have to answer this if you don't want to, but, like, how much does it typically cost to produce one of your events? 54:49 And I know that there's, like, different types, and I know that the first one was literally just happy hour at Hair of the Dog, Gloria's side, and, you know, that's maybe... 54:55 I don't know if you bought some drinks for people, maybe not. Um, but, uh, yeah, like, what does it really cost to put on the kind of event that you're putting on- Mm-hmm... that attracts, uh, brand partners? 55:06 Um, all in all our events cost, uh, upwards of 15K at the end of the day. Um-If we're doing, like, an event at the venue we've been doing at, frankly that, that's probably on the low end- Yeah... especially in New York. 55:17 And- And this is inclusive of, like, renting the venue and, like, maybe paying some staff- Yeah... and then also, uh, probably a bit of open bar and snacks, and that's- That's correct... that's it. 55:25 Food, beverage, um, the venue fees, videographer- Mm-hmm... content, you know, creation that's being used, maybe paying some volunteers or, or, you know, a- event, event, um, uh, ambassadors. Yeah. 55:39 Um, maybe some collateral merch, posters. All comes out to about 15K. 55:44 Um, I expect it to increase going into the new year, so that's why, like, you know, our sponsorships are very important to help us and able to do this, right? Yeah. Like, we don't do an event if we don't have a sponsor. 55:53 We just can't. 'Cause they have to cover the price, yeah. Right. Exactly. And, and, you know, we wanna keep doing these for the community, and they're great. 55:57 And so if we can get a sponsor to be a presenting partner and pay us anywhere from 20, 25, 30K, great. We can put on the event and do so in a really great way, um- Yeah... 56:06 while also, like, maintaining a sense of profitability so we can keep our operations running. Um, but that's ultimately, uh, what it costs. 56:12 You know, a dinner might be a little bit less expensive, anywhere from, like, 3 to 5K. Um, and then a smaller event, right, of course, like less than 15K or something. 56:20 But, you know, we have a sense of quality that we wanna maintain. There's, there's an expectation people have, and, um, you know, we, we want that to shine through, and that's why our sponsorships are what they are. 56:29 And we genuinely believe that the, the sponsors and partners do get really great value out of them, um, which is really important. Mm-hmm. Um, okay. 56:37 So you're, you earlier said that, you know, you wake up every day, you see yourself as a founder. You are the founder of Creator Economy NYC. 56:42 You are the co-founder of Syfty, uh, which I would love to give you a little chance to talk about what that is and how you came to co-found what I understand is basically an automated social listening software tool. 56:54 Mm-hmm. So Syfty, uh, is a comment section insights platform. So basically we are able to, um, analyze the comments on any public social post, be it owned, uh, earned, competitor, influencer, right? 57:07 Um, and, uh, uh, that idea actually came out of Creator Economy NYC- Mm... which is why Creator Economy NYC is so central to everything. The flywheel, buddy. We were at, we were at that first event, um, the... 57:18 not first event, it was our third event, and it was our first ever programming event with Tim Chiuzano, and I asked him, uh, on his pa- on our fireside chat, you know, he's been grow, bu- uh, growing so rapidly, you know, how does he deal with judgment happening in his comments? 57:32 Mm. 'Cause I saw that there was some hate. And he said that his wife reads him his comment section, right? And pulls out things to, to share and, like, what's going on. 'Cause he didn't wanna read it, right? No. 57:40 And so my now co-founder, who has a tech background and comes from, you know, the, uh, analytics world, we met at my second event ever, and we hit it off. 57:48 And he approached me after that event with Tim and was like, "Hey, you know, Tim talked about this thing about his wife does. 57:54 You know, I had this idea, you know, what if, like, basically you could see your comments by positive, negative, and neutral? 58:00 If I created this prototype from like one of Tim's pieces of content, would you send it to him?" And I was like, "Sure. Sounds good, dude. Whatever. Shoot me a message on LinkedIn." 58:07 And he messaged me, like, the prototype of it. I thought it was really cool. I didn't love the name or design of it. It was called Kelly AI, which is Tim's wife. And the design- [laughs]... 58:15 I was like, "This could be better." I, I, you know, have a very, as we discussed, great eye for design. Good eye. Yeah. Uh-huh. And I love design. 58:21 And so I just took a go in Figma at, like, redesigning this thing and renaming it. 58:25 And I la- literally landed on Syfty and, and, and, and this, like, clean design look, and so he, like, fixed that up, and then ultimately, like, we just started to work together on this project. 58:34 Um, and we were building Syfty to basically serve creators. Yeah. But I knew actually coming from the B2B world, being at Work Week, right, you know, building a platform- That's where the money is. [laughs] Right. 58:44 Like building a platform for creators is really difficult. Yeah. Um, and they're basically consumers, right? Yeah. And so we're gonna be like in every landscape. That's why all the main creator platforms are free to use. 58:52 Yeah. And, and it's gonna be really difficult. And I was like... Oh, and then through conversations we realized, wait, wait a minute, like, people that are running creator campaigns on behalf of brands 59:03 are looking at the comments, but they're doing so manually. So they're already collecting the links from all these creators when they're running their campaigns. 59:11 What if they could just, like, upload them into our platform and we'll analyze them for them, and they can view it from a grouping or individual lens? And, and that essentially is what led to what modern-day Syfty is. 59:22 Mm-hmm. And then we started to realize, like, okay, a lot of, like, insights and, and social listening teams at, at major brands and agencies also care about this stuff. 59:29 And, and now we've come, you know, we have customers like Lyft and Taco Bell and Hilton and Wasserman that are- I recognize those names... huge customers of Syfty- Mm... 59:38 um, which all started from this small little idea on a panel that I hosted, um, back in 2023. 59:44 And some of our earliest customers came from Creator Economy NYC when I would make Syfty the sponsor of the event, and I would shout out Syfty, and then they would come up to me after and be like, "What was that tool you mentioned?" 59:54 And it would get a demo, and it would lead to us, us, you know, basically them becoming customers. So- No, but this is, this is very fuck it, create it. It's very fuck it, create it. 1:00:02 [laughs] Um, and, and I always felt very, a- as slow as the growth has been for Syfty, right, I've always been very passionate that we were gonna figure it out. The signals were there. Yeah. 1:00:10 We just needed things to click more, and I stayed true to this motto, and, uh, here we are. You know, we fuck it, created both of these things. Who knows what- Mm... we'll fuck it, create it next. Cool. 1:00:20 Um, and it's a really exciting journey to be on both the community and creator side and also on the, um, uh, software platform- Yeah... side. 1:00:28 To that point, uh, like, uh, you know, this is a question people always like, "Where do you see yourself in five years?" I don't think it's a very good question. Nobody knows. 1:00:35 Where, what would you like to be spending your time on one year from now, as well as three years from now? Mm-hmm. Great question. 1:00:42 One year from now I'd like to be in kind of more of a, um, like, president role of Creator Economy NYC, so, like, we have some operations in place. 1:00:50 And then, you know, for Syfty, I, I just foresee it becoming, you know, continuing to grow and, and I'd love to, you know, be the CEO o- of Syfty while still having this community arm that I almost feel like I'm, you know, I'm do- doing a service for the community with Creator Economy NYC. 1:01:05 Yeah. You know, five years from now, I, I, I see that both of these entities are acquirable. Hmm. Who, who does that potential partner look like to help take these things to the next level? 1:01:18 And, um, you know, I, I can-Start maybe work more on just being the, the element of talent or, or creating content. Um, but I don't know. I, I, I always get these, these urges and ideas to create another brand. 1:01:31 Right now I have no bandwidth, and I, I'm very focused on what I'm building currently. 1:01:35 But I imagine when time frees up, you know, there's gonna be something else that I wanna create that I think will be in the social media space for sure. Yeah. Um, but I don't foresee that being for another 10-plus years. 1:01:45 And- Well, w-one final-- I'm good... in fact, I'm, I'm ready to lock in, by the way, for 25 years doing this, both these things, right? Mm-hmm. And I think that's a big thing for people to think about. 1:01:54 Could you be doing these things for 25 years? That's [chuckles] a tough question. Um- That's how I think. Okay. Well, wait- And I'm like, "I'm ready to just do it." With, with, you know, with... 1:02:01 If Creator Economy NYC is acquirable, we were talking earlier about how part of what makes it work is that it's not owned by a brand, and it's, it's like this- Yeah... 1:02:09 thing that like, oh, my friend Brett puts this on or whatever it is, or this guy Brett, he puts this on. Whatever it is, right? It's, it's, it's because it's you, and it's not, like, tied to a specific- Right... 1:02:18 economic outcome for one brand. So, you know, where my mind goes is who would acquire this. Um, one possible thing is, like, maybe it's an agency and, like, as, as- Yeah... 1:02:26 you know, create-- not just creator agencies are normalized but just, like, you know, classic talent agencies have more creator, um, clients. To that point, like, that seems like something you would excel at. 1:02:36 You know, we were talking about how you're a relationships business guy. Um, would you... Is that a business you would start or be interested in being party to, some sort of creator talent agency? Not at all. Ah. 1:02:47 I have no interest in doing- Interesting... anything with talent or agency. I just, I just think, like, right now, and it's just, like, complex. And also- 'Cause that's kind of what you were doing with Work Week, right? 1:02:55 Uh, I was mainly like, uh, like an operator manager to an extent. Yeah. Um, you know, the talent was in-house for like a good- What about at Kickstarter, where you were head of creators? 1:03:03 Right, right, and that was more of like a bus- a brand, a brand... uh, sorry, a business development type of role- Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah... where, like, uh, kinda like bringing creators in. 1:03:10 But no, I'm not, I'm not really interested in talent management, um, or, or doing the agency role. I think it's just, like, a lot. Um- Yeah... I, I really love, you know, community. I love tech. 1:03:20 I, I really love tech and, and building things that, like, people can experience and tangibly feel, which is why, like, yes, software platform, great. Like, I designed Sipsey. 1:03:28 I love the fact that people think it's so clean and great to use, and my events, right? I love that, like, people can give me feedback that they love the experience of it. So I just, I like those elements to execute on. 1:03:38 Um, you make a, yeah, a great point in terms of, like, who should acquire. I don't know. I mean, it could be... Like, you know, you see a lot of agencies that are doing their community thing, like Whalar- Mm-hmm... 1:03:47 just launched the Lighthouse. Um, some other brands are doing it, like Billion Dollar Boy. Could they be potential partners? For sure, absolutely. Um, could it be a media and events business? For sure as well. 1:03:58 Um, am I ready to have any, like, acquisition? No. Think there's still a lot more for us to build. But, like, that's what I think about, and I do think it's important that, like, 1:04:06 um, you know, I, I want what will be best for, um, a, a business outcome, right? Like, at a, at a certain point, I need to start... I need to extract value- Yeah... a certain value from this. 1:04:16 I think that's, like, fair to say as a business owner, right? Like- Certainly... um, and then how do I do that in a way that isn't detrimental to what has been so authentic and true to this community? 1:04:28 Um, and, and maybe one day I'll have the luxury of crossing that bridge when we get there. Yeah. Well, okay, enough, you know, future speculation. Okay. This episode will come out about mid-December 2025. 1:04:39 Um, do you have any events or anything planned early 2026, anything on the books already that- Great question... listeners should look out for? Well, next event's with Shopify on December 3rd, 2025. 1:04:50 But 2026, uh, we're still planning out, uh, but we do plan to have an event with Teachable, uh, likely at the end of January. So, uh, keep your calendars open for the last week of January. 1:05:02 Um, we plan to have something happen then. Perfect. Well, Brett, that is it. Thank you for coming on. Thank you so much for having me. This was a blast. Perfect. Listener, we will see you next week. 1:05:13 [upbeat music] If you just listened to that episode with Brett, why not listen to our previous episode with his brother, Jared, where he talks about how they built their newsletter, Healthcare Huddle? 1:05:24 It was the eighth episode on this channel before we even had video, so it's also a great look back on how far this channel has come since the very beginning. [upbeat music]