Transcript 0:00 We were the first agency ever to pay out a million dollars to LinkedIn creators. You're managing eight figures in spend at your agency. How are you determining this is the fee the creator gets? 0:09 What brands are looking for today is, like, the highest possible quality. AI-generated content and AI-generated influencers is bringing everything to zero. The only last moat left is brand. 0:18 We're seeing a shift from demand to brand. There's still not enough good storytelling. There's a lot of content, but there aren't that many amazing storytellers yet, and that really helps you stand out. 0:28 The only signal that rises above the noise is storytelling creators. How much of your inbound is from your content? The best opportunities are always outbound. No one's gonna throw your hat in the ring. 0:40 You have to throw your own hat in the ring. This applies in, in so many areas of business. In anything. No one's gonna save you. 0:48 AJ, you are the founder of Creator Match, which has started as a agency connecting brands with B2B creators on LinkedIn. 0:57 You've since expanded to B2B creators across platforms, and more recently into setting up creator programs for these brands. 1:06 But just to contextualize for the listener, that's the basic TLDR of what you do, what Creator Match is. Yeah, now, you know, we, we build creator programs for the fastest-growing tech brands in the world. 1:16 The tech brands could be B2B, they could be AI, they could be just SaaS in general. 1:21 You know, I think early on you have to niche down, whether you're a creator and you're niching down on your own content, whether you're a brand and niching down on who you're trying to serve, and then over time you start to expand. 1:30 I love to give this analogy where, you know, when you are an early stage founder and you are a first-time founder like myself, you wanna try to own the entire swimming pool. 1:39 But instead of trying to own the swimming pool, you need to own one swim lane. If you give the analogy of sports, there's never the best swimmer in the world. There's never the best runner in the world. 1:48 It's the best- Hmm... runner for the 300-yard dash. It's the best runner for a certain stroke of swimming. And then over time, once you start nailing these swim lanes, you can add more. 1:58 But to do everything, you do nothing. And early on we nailed LinkedIn creative marketing. Once we started nailing that, brands asked, "Hey, we want more. We want more." Okay, well, what do you want? 2:06 And then they told us what they wanted, and now we do all channels. We do, you know, more than just B2B, but all things really tech creator marketing. Mm-hmm. I have to give you credit for this analogy. 2:15 This is very much the, the TED Talk speaker in you coming out. I have done one. I did one last year, and it was... That's in a whole other, whole other rabbit hole we can go down, but that was, uh, a very fun moment. 2:25 Okay. Well, we'll get to that a little later. Um, but one more contextualizing question I wanna ask you, just to somehow contextualize the scale of your business. 2:33 Is there any number you can give our listeners for that purpose, whether it's some average deal cost, margin, total bookings from last year, whatever it is, any number you are comfortable sharing to establish what your business is doing? 2:45 So our business, think of it like an ad agency, where we are really a bank, that we manage a lot of money. So brands give us anywhere from, you know, it could be six figures, it could be seven figures in a wallet. 2:59 A wallet could be tied to a campaign, it could be tied to a period of time. And then we essentially deploy capital as effe- uh, as efficiently as possible and as fast as possible with creators. 3:09 So in year one, in a 12-month span, we hit a million dollars in essentially managed creator spend, and that was just on LinkedIn. We were the first agency ever to pay out a million dollars to LinkedIn creators. 3:23 Then in year two, we hit that number much sooner, and we were doing it through general- Which I should say, year two is wrapping up in this June. Correct. You are at the two-year mark, essentially. Correct. 3:33 Literally, when this comes out, we will be at, at year two. Yeah. And then we hit that number, um, in just a couple of months across multiple channels, and now we're doing that essentially every month. 3:43 So the goal is now to manage over a million dollars a month in, instead of media or ad spend, creator spend across all channels. Hmm. And we have brands really spending across the gambit. 3:53 Some brands spend, you know, maybe mid five figures a month, some brands are six figures a month, and then some brands are like, "I need to go crazy for a launch, and I need to literally spend seven figures for this month or the next two months." 4:04 So, I mean, we are managing millions upon millions of dollars, and we have to now have a whole bank strategy for the amount of money that we manage across different banks because we're hitting FDIC insurance limits. 4:15 Um, but the good thing is, like, this money is, is sending-- We're just passing money through to creators- Hmm... and spending it effectively, um, for, for brands. So we are 35 people now. Um, last year- Wow... 4:26 it was, like, just myself and an AI, [laughs] AI notetaker, so we have 35 people now. We work with, you know, anywhere from maybe 10 brands a month, 30 brands a month. Each brand can have multiple campaigns. 4:37 I mean, it is like a full-on operation, and it is no longer just a, a one-person show, so a lot of the operation, uh, focus comes in, which is why we brought on an incredible COO, uh, shout out Tara Knight, and then a whole operations team and AI efficiencies and account leads and account managers. 4:53 So it is a full-on business. And I've done a lot of side hustles over the years. This is the first one where it's like, okay, like this is-- We have HR. This is not a side hustle. This is not a side hustle anymore. 5:01 This is-- I mean, we have people. We have, we have health insurance. Several people on the team are making over six figures. I mean, our, our headcount alone, our payroll alone is, I mean, is, is massive. 5:10 So it's really cool to now, okay, like, let's get to work. Yeah. Let's talk about those creators. So you've got this m- probably massive, like, across all possible campaigns sourcing sheet, right? 5:22 How many creators are you tracking in total right now? Yeah, we're not actively tracking them, you know, on a, on a daily or weekly basis, but our creator network is in- Yeah... is in the thousands. 5:31 And, you know, there are-- There, there's no, if you think about, like, supply and demand, there's no shortage of creators wanting to get paid as much as there are brands willing to pay. Yeah. 5:42 And I always remind creators that reach out, "Hey, where's our brand deals? Where's our brand deals?" And I say, "You know, there's a lot of people that wanna get paid." So I- it's in... 5:51 I'm, I'm agency, so I will literally tell you, "It's in your best interest to go out and actually kind of fend for yourself and go fish for yourself. 5:58 Like, don't wait for someone else to go fish and kind of bring you food on the table." 6:02 And we can definitely walk through the same practices that we do as an agency for the entire process, and the more you can understand it, it's almost like a job seeker understanding how recruiting works- Mm-hmm... 6:11 on, on their side as a recruiter, the, the more successful you can become. So you should be pitching yourself to brands directly. You should be making your own media kit. 6:18 You should be putting yourself in a position to be successful. You should be meeting as many brand side agencies as you can, not just the Creator Matches of the world, right? 6:26 Because, like, it is in your best interest to do what we're doing on the, the brand side, but you on the talent side. Um, and those are some things that I think creators don't realize. 6:34 They, I think, creators just expect everything to be inbound. But I will say this, the best opportunities are always outbound. Even when you mentioned TED Talk in the beginning, Mr. Ted didn't come knock on my door. 6:44 [laughs] Right? 6:45 Like, there's a whole process for getting a TED Talk, and we can walk through it a- a- if you're interested, but like- Well, we can s- I mean, we can, we can sum it up very well in that you've pitched yourself to come on this podcast a couple times and, you know, when I finally said yes, you had pitched me, "Here's the angle. 6:59 Here's what the title of the podcast would probably be, the title of the newsletter. Here are the, all the angles I could talk about." It's y- you're, you're making it very... 7:07 You're making the decision much easier because you are outsourcing the thinking to yourself. The person you're pitching doesn't have to do the thinking. You've done it for them. 7:14 Like, this, this applies in, in so many different business- In anything. And, and I've always been someone where it's like, no one's gonna throw your hat in the ring. You have to throw your own hat in the ring. Yeah. 7:22 No one's gonna, no one's gonna save you, right? I've always had that- Okay, well, well, so in, in this tracking sheet though- Sure... 7:27 you know, I'm, I'm assuming there's a literal spreadsheet or many literal spreadsheets. What are the columns? 7:31 What are the things that you are putting in there that tell you that these are creators we might wanna work with or not? Yeah, so, so as a creator listening, ask yourself how you can de-risk yourself to join a campaign. 7:44 So working with creators versus just using, let's say, paid media on, like, running meta ads, let's say, or YouTube ads, is way riskier because there's so much more unknown and it's way harder to track. 7:55 So you are already riskier than, like, the traditional media sense. So how do you de-risk yourself, whether the brand's working with you directly or whether you're working with an agency? 8:04 Because, like, the creators that we're bringing to these brands, we obviously wanna run the best performing campaign, so creators need to think about how to de-risk yourself. 8:13 So a couple of the columns as an example, so you have your normal, like, your name, your profile, your follower count, links to your, um, you know, your profiles, right? 8:22 Like, your Instagram, your TikTok, your LinkedIn, whatever it is. But some of the other ones, it's like, do you use the product, right? Mm-hmm. 8:28 Like, if you use Claude, and I can prove that, whether you've shared that with me, you're a power... Like, don't say you're a power user and you never even logged on to the, the portal or, or the site, right? 8:39 So if you use the product, that's very helpful, right? Like, we were talking about Riverside, connecting you with the Riverside team. Mm-hmm. 8:43 You being a power user is very, very easy and helpful because you know how to use the product, right? The second thing is, if I'm the brand, I want to envision what my sponsored post will look like in your feed. 8:56 So if you only make, let's say, carousel content, and I'm looking for a video post, it's very hard for me to think about what Francis will look like on video- Yeah... if you've never made a video, right? 9:09 So, you know, one of the biggest things as you're thinking about this is make it so simple, like dead simple, for the brand to clearly understand where they fit in, because it's not... 9:19 I always say, like, it doesn't need to be on brand for the brand. It needs to be on brand for the creator. Yes. Right? 9:26 So, you know, with that, have you ever actually made a con- piece of content talking about, let's say, Claude, right? If you have, and if... And it performed well, it's really easy to pitch that to the brand. 9:36 Okay, but maybe you've never mentioned a post about Claude. 9:38 Have you mentioned a post about Perplexity or Cla- or, uh, ChatGPT, or really any AI tool to show that your audience likes this, has this appetite of, you know, tools in the AI space? Okay, maybe that's not checked off. 9:49 Okay. Well, have you ever made a video with a brand that has performed well? Okay, great. Maybe it wasn't sponsored. Okay. 9:56 Like, as you keep kinda going back and back in terms of levels, like the perfect, the most ideal state is you've made a post about my brand already for free. It performed well. Now I'll pay you. 10:05 And you kinda just keep going backwards in terms of these, these levels or checks, but then the farther back you go, the harder it is to pitch because, like, the brand and the agency will go back and forth on kind of deciding if they should approve or reject these creators on a sourcing list, and it's in your job as a creator to make sure that you get on the sourcing list, number one, and then you get approved in the sourcing list. 10:25 Mm-hmm. H- uh, how has the way, over the last two years of you running your, your company, how has the way you're sourcing and grading changed? 10:33 I'm sure that, you know, y- the, the people you're working with, actual brands you're working with, they have gotten more sophisticated in what they're looking for and their demands. 10:41 So yeah, like, what's different about the way you're sourcing and grading today compared to two years ago? Yeah, it's funny. 10:46 I think there's, there's way more tools out there, um, and I think the tools are helpful from a performance standpoint. 10:52 It's like very quickly there's some Chrome extensions where I can go into your Instagram and very quickly see your median, um, you know, uh, impressions or views tied to Reels, let's say, or- Can you... 11:01 What's the wor- What is that Chrome extension? Um, the tool is called Profile Plus. Mm-hmm. And it's just one of the tools that one of the brands that we're using, um, was kind of mentioning, so we use it as well. 11:12 Um, so, like, that's good from a performance standpoint. But assuming that you have good performance, a- and the biggest thing also for creators is, like, you need to have some reach. You could have the- Yeah... 11:21 like, everything else checked off and, like, the best content ever, but if no one's seeing it, it's, it's hard to sponsor a creator that things seen by five people. Yeah. 11:28 Unless it's for ads, which is a different story, but for now, let's just say it's mostly sponsored. 11:33 So, you know, with, with this whole world of, of kind of reviewing creators, the funny thing, and I've confirmed this with brands, is as AI gets better and better and the tools get better, 11:43 there's still not a perfect tool to identify taste. 11:47 And brands today, at least the brands that we are working with, really want storytelling creators because it's so loud in this AI world and there's so much noise, the only signal that rises above the noise is storytelling creators. 12:02 So if I'm a creator And I'm thinking about where I play on the spectrum of content and quality. I would try to go as high up as possible in terms of storytelling. 12:13 It does not need to be that you need 18 camera shots and, you know, spend $20,000 per video and then go like MrBeast level, but the storytelling needs to be so strong, and that really is what brands are looking for today, is, like, the highest possible quality because UGC and AI-generated content and AI-generated influencers is bringing everything to zero. 12:34 Mm-hmm. But, like, you can't replicate good storytelling. You know, I- So then I'm sure... this is funny, actually... you know... 12:39 I, I did an episode with one of your competitors, I think, Vin Matano, right, uh, of Creator Buzz, and he said essentially the same thing. He said on LinkedIn it's still, there's still not enough good storytelling. 12:50 There's a lot of content, but there aren't that many amazing storytellers yet, and that really helps you stand out. 12:57 And I think also, you know, when we're thinking about this world of, of AI, it's being less of a creator that just talks about features that launched with these brands- Mm-hmm... 13:06 but more about what we call use case marketing or use case creators. 13:09 So an example is I'm sure everyone here follows certain creators, say, on Instagram, where you know when you go to their profile, like, there is value, like, really being a value-based creator. 13:20 And, you know, the creators in, like, ManyChat is a great example as well, where they give you an amazing workflow and you're like, "Oh my God, I need that prompt. I need that workflow." 13:28 Comment Francis to get, you know, the, uh, the lead magnet, whatever it is, right? But, like, you don't have to do it for every piece of content, but those do really well, especially from a brand performance standpoint. 13:39 So ask yourself, like, are people just following you as from a lifestyle standpoint? Are they following you because you are giving them the keys for better use cases for their niche? 13:48 And, you know, we think about this, this model as well of the Mount Rushmore approach in terms of creator marketing. 13:55 So, like, if I'm running a campaign for X, Y, Z brand, I'm gonna go source, like, do smaller sourcing lists per niche. Mm-hmm. 14:01 So maybe it's the sales niche, the marketing niche, the, um, finance niche, and then in those niches you have those main creators, but then in those creators, if you're a finance, uh, creator, be that creator people follow for the best use cases. 14:14 And back then it was, like, the Excel tips and tricks, and now it's, like, how to use Perplexity Finance to build out a personal, uh, finance dashboard- Yeah... to kind of going through all those things. 14:25 So, like, think about use case marketing over feature marketing because value will outperform today. Yeah. What might disqualify a creator from getting on your list? 14:36 Or what might get them taken off of your list and even blacklisted? So I think, I guess the, there's two parts there. One is, is not getting on it in the first place. 14:43 The second one is being on it, but then essentially being blacklisted. So the first one of not being on it, I think you definitely have to have some reach. Mm-hmm. 14:49 Again, like, at the end of the day, you're the best creator ever, amazing content, but brands are working with you because they want to join your world, and you have to have people following you, um, and, and people seeing it. 14:59 So you have to have some reach. 15:01 I think if you are saying that you are a power user of a brand, but it's so obvious that you've never worked with them before, or, like, we're working with you and then you, you don't even know how to, how to use the most basic things, I think that's, that's very obvious. 15:12 It's very inauthentic. 15:14 Um, I also think that, you know, to not get on a sourcing list, I think you, especially on LinkedIn, there are some creators that actually crush it from a reach standpoint, but the content is just, is just bad. 15:26 So, like, an example is we call them the, um, billboard creators. 15:30 So, like, there's been this trend where it's AI-generated billboards, and they crush for whatever reason, but there's no place for brands to, to live in that type of content, and it's very fluffy, very high level. 15:42 So, like, that is the creator that checks off reach with us and check off storytelling quality or use case marketing. 15:48 On the other side of [laughs] of never working with us again is, like, if you are just a nightmare to work with. We get that shit happens. We get that things are tough. 15:56 We get that everyone has side hustles and multiple jobs. 16:00 But, like, if we are chasing you to send an invoice, if we are having to fly out to your house and knock on your door to send your analytics, if we are, you know, doing the, like, the, the bare minimum requests and you're not even able to respond and we have to get creative about how we're texting you or reaching out to you, we're just not gonna try to work with you again because, you know, we have the ability to work with any creator. 16:22 But also it's, on the flip side, it's, like, the creators that do bend over backwards that are amazing to us that, you know, we're like, "Hey, you know what? 16:28 I'm s- I, I wanna apologize, like, this past post did not go well. I think here's why. Let me do a make good post for you, and let me, let me, like, throw you guys a mention in my newsletter, which has 100,000 people. 16:38 It's not paid for, but, like, I want to, to make this right." They treat it like a business, and I think that's also one of the best quotes is, like, they treat this like a business. This is not a side hustle for us. 16:47 It's not a side hustle for the brand. It might be a side hustle for you, but you can't treat it like a side hustle for you and everyone else. Well, it's not, it's not transactional the way you're describing it. 16:53 It's not transactional. It's business is relationships. Of course. This is, like- It's all... cultivating that... it's all relationships. 16:58 And I guarantee you the brand also has the favorite creators they work with, not just from a performance standpoint, because we've had creators that perform very well, but they are nightmares to work with. 17:07 Unless the brand says, "I wanna specifically work with this creator," we're not gonna go out of our way to make our lives more difficult, right? Versus the creators that are just a joy and a delight to work with. 17:17 If you're a creator, you probably did not get into this to spend hours uploading files, writing tags, organizing assets, and digging through analytics. That's why OpenVideo built an MCP server just for creators. 17:28 It lets an AI agent manage the operational side of your video business from a single prompt, uploading, tagging, organizing, and analyzing your entire channel for you. 17:37 And unlike traditional platforms, it all happens on infrastructure you control. So let AI do the busywork while you do the important work of creating content your audience can't live without. 17:48 See how you can do more with AI at open.video/mcp. That's open.video/mcp. 17:57 So I, I wanna ask how you Set up, run a campaign basically from soup to nuts, and the two things in my mind, one, at the very beginning of this, you said that your company essentially acts like a bank, where you are being given this large budget, however large it is, could be, you know, seven figures, as you said, for some of these clients. 18:14 They're giving you that budget, and then it's there, so you can execute. 18:17 And such as on these, you know, very quick turnaround projects, you can just tell this creator, "We're gonna do it," and I don't know how quickly you're paying them, but you can go and do this without a lot of back and forth between you and the brand because you've sort of set these ground rules and their goals. 18:30 So starting with a brand coming to you, and you're negotiating budget and goals, walk me through how you're then taking that, deciding that, that number, bringing it in, and then later deploying it, and then reporting on it. 18:44 Yeah. So, you know, the goal for, for any of our brand partners is to become their agency of record over a long period of time. 18:50 So it's, yes, we do, we still do a lot of one-off campaigns, "Hey, we have a launch coming up. Here's the budget, here's what we're thinking." 18:57 Um, the goal is that we are, you know, 6 to 12 month partners, and then we are, you know, agreeing on, let's say, a million dollars in the span of a year in terms of, of creator spend. 19:07 And then very important for the audience as well is, like, we don't keep a million dollars, right? 19:11 A million dollars is for the creators, and then how we monetize is either a monthly retainer to manage the spend or a percentage of the budget. 19:19 But when we say, "Hey, Francis, here's the rate, $2,000, $5,000 a, uh, $5,000 a post," you keep 100% of that. We are not your manager. 19:26 We just send you deal flow, which is, it's kind of the optimal, uh, experience for creators. We manage everything. 19:31 So once, you know, the brand and us as the agency creator match agree on a budget, we then think about, okay, like, what's the strategy here, right? 19:40 We always ask, we never take on a campaign unless we can agree with the brand on what the goal is. And the goal will have qualitative metrics and quantitative metrics. 19:47 The three buckets of goals we usually put them towards is top of funnel, brand awareness, with a CPM goal, could be $50, $100, whatever it is. 19:58 The next bucket is bottom of funnel, uh, metric usually tied to conversion, revenue, clicks, right? Very bottom of funnel. And the last bucket, which is this new emerging bucket, which we can talk about, is AI search. 20:11 So sometimes brands will say, "Hey, I wanna work with creators because I want more people talking about us that don't work at our company." And that's a big trend, just creator marketing for AI search. 20:21 Once we align on one, if not multiple goals, we then build out the campaign brief. We think about the strategy, we think about what the best channels are. 20:28 We're now, you know, we do all channels now, all, uh, short form channels, long form channels. It could be newsletter, there could be some paid media we're gonna add. It can even be an IRL component. 20:37 So we do a lot of, of in-person. It could be, let's do an in-person event. Let's do a creator dinner. Let's do, you know, uh, an event tied to another conference like a Cannes Lions or a South by Southwest. 20:48 Um, it could be let's do gifting, physical gifting tied to this. So we, based on that, let's say it's $200,000, we think about, you know, what your goals are, what are the best channels and kind of ways to get there. 20:59 Should we go after just a few large creators? Should we go, go after more small creators? Should we have a mix of the two? 21:04 So, like, that's where all the strategy comes in and kind of understanding the direction of the compass we're about to point and then sprint to. Then we actually build out the campaign brief. 21:12 We then start with a sourcing list. We build out the sourcing list based on those, that criteria. We send that to the brand. The brand reviews it, approves it, has some comments. We go back and forth. 21:21 Once we lock in, okay, of the 200 names we sent you, these 50 are approved, we then go out, outreach to those, uh, 50 that are approved. Some of them might be creators we've worked with before. 21:31 Some of them might be kind of net new creators, so we're working on building those relationships. We go back and forth for a couple days to a week on rate negotiation, "Hey, the brand is Microsoft. 21:40 They wanna work with you. The brief is X, Y, Z. Here's what we think, you know, uh, you're worth in terms of content." They used to back and forth with their manager, get that locked in, sign contracts. 21:50 Here's the draft document. You start drafting the content, go back and forth with the brand and the creator on couple rounds of revision. Content goes live. 21:59 Once the content goes live, we're monitoring it, um, we engage with it, we collect analytics, and then we do a wrap report into the campaign. 22:05 So, you know, it's a pretty drawn out process, but in these fast flips, that's all condensed into, like, could be two weeks, right, from start to finish. Yeah. 22:13 Well, but when you're doing these fast flips, like, what has been predetermined with the brand to, to where then you are authorized to just sort of go, and I'm, I imagine you guys are making the decisions- Correct... 22:22 a lot of it is going back to the brand. So we, we basically say, you know, if there's normally X number of revisions and back and forth, like, we don't have time for that, right? Yeah. 22:29 So it might be that we get blanket approval on the creators that we source and approve. It might be blanket approval on the content that goes live. 22:35 Um, or it might be like, "Hey, instead of giving you three days to get back to us, like, we need same day approval." 22:40 So, like, everything is very, very, very fast, and we make it very evident to the creator, "Hey, this is gonna be a fast flip. Get ready. And, you know, if you want it, amazing. If you don't want it, amazing." 22:50 So it's, it's, everything is just moving a million miles a second, and it's in your best interest as a creator to move fast in this ad world. Yeah. 22:57 I'm curious how you are determining fees for creators, and I'm- I'm hearing that there's basically three things. There's one, like, what the brand is probably giving you as a ceiling for any given- Mm-hmm... 23:06 creator, any given engagement. Two, there's obviously the creator's reach. Three, there's the who is in the audience of the creator. Four, there's, like, that more taste factor, right? Like, is the storytelling there? 23:17 Is this content that, like, we really want this brand to be associated with? But beyond that, like, how are you determining this is the fee the creator gets? Yeah. 23:25 Well, we, we try to be super unbiased in how we do, um, you know, just rates with creators. I think it's always definitely this, this black box of no one really knows how to go about rates. 23:37 I think at the end of the day, the most objective way to do, um, you know, to understand rates is just CPM. 23:43 So if you have, you know, X thousand dollars and in a median sense, so don't-- And this is important for creators as well, is 23:50 if you h- if you average 10,000 views, let's say, on your Instagram Reels or your LinkedIn content, whatever it is, and then one post gets, like, 5 million views and popped off- You shouldn't just take the average of that because it's gonna be skewed so high because of that one outlier. 24:07 And the irony is, even if you get the brand to bite on that, they're gonna expect whatever the, the average is, let's say it's now 100,000 instead of 10,000, and you know that your actual average is 10,000, the brand bought for 100,000, you got a higher price because of it, and it doesn't perform, and you don't get renewed. 24:24 Like, your singular goal as a creator, anytime you're doing a small test, a pilot, one-off or a couple one-offs, is to get renewed. Like, there should be no other goal other than that. Yeah. 24:35 But to do that, like, how do you get renewed, right? And there's the intangibles, like being a good person to work with, being responsive, h- you know, good content quality. 24:43 If you have to make good, think about what the make, make good would be. But also, like, if you set yourself up to fail, because, like, at the end of the day, when the campaign wraps, we look at eCPM per creator. 24:54 So everyone, not just the CPM for the campaign, but CPM per creator. And like, and when we're going down that list, we wanna see a really low CPM because it's like, oh my God, of course we're gonna rebook Francis. Yeah. 25:06 Even if you know that you under, underpriced yourself, you're now gonna get rebooked for a much larger partnership, or at least be, guess what? 25:13 Let's say this is a campaign with, you know, Zapier, and Zapier is, is pausing influencer efforts for now, but we know you crushed. Guess what? We work with Whisperflow. 25:21 It's like we're gonna pull you into the next campaign with a different brand for us, right? So, like, it's in your best interest to price fairly based on what you think you can actually achieve. 25:30 If you go too high, short-term win, long-term loss. So I think CPM is a big part of it, and like really just better understanding, you know, I think tech CPMs in the space. 25:39 If you've worked with other competitors in the space, I think it's, you can definitely charge more. 25:44 If you are, you know, requested by the brand because they, they know you're one of the top voices, you can definitely charge more. 25:50 If you have a high-value audience, let's say you are a top accounting voice, you have 5,000 followers on LinkedIn, very highly engaged, and it's all CPAs, you're gonna charge more, for sure. 26:00 Um, I also think that you never wanna just sell one-off channels. 26:05 It's in your best interest to also say, "Hey, based off of this brief, I think I should sell my newsletter, my Instagram, and even long-form YouTube video." Right? 26:13 Because, like, you can kinda blend your C- your eCPM as a creator. So it's definitely not just an art or just a science. It, it's a bit of both. But typically, we're backing into just, like, a very fair CPM. 26:24 You give us the data based off your analytics, and we, we kind of respond back with, "Okay, based on this and based on, like, our target CPM for this campaign, we're able to charge you X." That makes sense. 26:34 I-- While you were talking, I was thinking about this, um, story somebody I interviewed around the turn of the year told me where former, like, professional journalist who then went independent and had a goal of, I think, you know, making, making back everything they'd invested in gear and stu- and such within six months, something like that. 26:52 But anyways, their first video on YouTube hit big, and then they had some incoming requests for sponsorships, and they're like, "This is amazing. I'm good." None of those sponsorships closed for about six months. 27:03 And the, what he said, which [chuckles] I think about, I think about quite often, is he was like, "You know, I was in this mindset of, like, know your worth, but I didn't really know my worth," right? 27:12 Where he wasn't being realistic, and this is, this is kind of what you're talking about, about, like, swinging for that big, like, oh, he-- "Look, I did this, so now you should pay me this," when in reality, your average is much lower, and you wanna be thinking in, in, in terms of, like, "Oh, I, I wanna get the fourth deal with these guys." 27:29 Correct. The f- the first is just an avenue to the fourth. The money is never in the first. It's in the second or the third, right? It's like, prove your... Think of it like an internship. 27:38 Like, why would you hurt your chances of getting the full-time job? In, in analogy, right? So don't-- Like, I think too many creators think short term. 27:48 And I'm not saying that you should be getting paid under market value, but don't set yourself up to fail or the agency up to fail as well. Mm-hmm. Yeah. 27:58 Um, I have not worked with marketers who are buying LinkedIn ads for a little while. I mean, like, the, the, on the platform, like, using their native advertising tools. 28:08 But I remember a couple years ago when I was still working with marketers like this, it was very expensive, and it was really hard to justify, why don't we just put that money in Meta, in Google, in creator marketing, right? 28:20 How does a-- Let's-- Keeping it on LinkedIn, how does a LinkedIn creator campaign that you would run with a brand compare to this platform native formal advertising in terms of cost and ROI? 28:32 So LinkedIn is by far the most expensive channel, I would say, to run ads. 28:37 I mean, it's such a high-value, affluent, educated audience that LinkedIn knows that, which is why the CPMs, even from an ad standpoint, is incredibly, incredibly expensive. 28:50 That said, you know, and it's really important also to think about, like, what you're competing against. So when we're pitching LinkedIn creator marketing to a brand, we can go to their ads library on LinkedIn. 29:01 It's public. Every company that r- every social media platform that has an ads, um, side to the company has a, I think it's legally required to have a public- Yeah... ad library. Meta has it as well. 29:13 So I will go and say, okay, let's say if I'm on Notion. I'll just type in Notion and say, "Okay, here are your ads." And if I think that we, from a, you know, content standpoint can beat this, I say, "Great." 29:23 I think that, like, it's all static carousels, and, like, there's no humans involved, and there's no storytelling. 29:29 So oftentimes, like, we're less competing against other channels and more about like, "Hey, let's try to allocate more of that paid media budget to creators." But it's not just creator content. 29:38 It's boosting the creator content for ads. So also, you know, if I'm a creator listening to this, it's so important to think about usage rights. And if the brand's not doing it, asking them, "Why are you not doing it?" 29:50 And on certain platforms like LinkedIn, you can boost your own content as well. You don't have to be a media buyer. So the highest performing ad type factually right now on the platform is LinkedIn thought leader ads. 30:03 Traditionally, it was, let's say it was, um, you know, Tesla boosting Elon Musk's content. Right, it was, it was a company boosting their own thought leaders. 30:13 And then they added over the last few months the ability to boost third-party content not affiliated with your brand. So that is by far the highest performing ad type right now on LinkedIn. 30:21 We will not do a campaign right now unless the brand is allowing us to boost the content from our paid media team or the brand's doing it themselves. 30:28 But almost all the content's getting boosted because the CPM, the organic CPM, is so high, it could be in the six fig- or, uh, sorry, in the three figures, right? In the hundreds of dollars, which is insane for a CPM. 30:38 But then with the ads, you can bring it down to a very low kind of two-digit CPM. 30:43 Like, that is the only way I think to win right now on LinkedIn, is getting creators to create content for the brand and doing a mix of different formats. 30:50 It could be video, it could be image, whatever it is, and then working with the brand to actually boost that content. Like, if you're a creator, make sure that the b- the brand is, if it's good content- Mm-hmm... 31:00 boosting the content for, um, for influencer ROI listening. If you're building your whole video business on platforms like YouTube, here's the uncomfortable truth: they own the audience relationship, not you. 31:11 That's where OpenVideo comes in. It lets you host your videos on your own domain under your own brand, so you control the channel, the data, and the direct connection to your viewers. 31:19 And now, with the new OpenVideo MCP server, you can do even more without taking your focus off of your content. 31:26 With their MCP server, an AI agent can upload, tag, organize, and even analyze your entire video library from a single prompt. Your video stays yours, the busy work gets automated, and you can focus on creating. 31:38 Check out OpenVideo for all the details. That's open.video. You said that you are still really the only salesperson, essentially. How much of your inbound is from your content, like from AJ on LinkedIn? Mm-hmm. 31:53 How much of it is just from now the Creator Match reputation has grown and, and it's all word of mouth? I would say early on it was 100%. I call it outbound content to inbound- Mm... DMs. 32:04 So 100% of it was from the build in public content that we created, especially through my LinkedIn profile. I would say now instead of it being 100 to zero, it's probably 50/50, 50% inbound, 50% word of mouth. 32:19 The beauty of working in a world where everyone talks is that they talk, and that's a, that's a blessing and a curse. 32:27 [laughs] Because if you shit the bed on a campaign, they talk, but if you crush it for them, they will scream from the rooftops. And, like, the joke that we always give what our, our metric of success is, is how do I... 32:38 Like, let's say you're the brand. How do I get you promoted? 32:42 How do I get you to love us so much to where if you were to leave this company and go to the next company, the first order of business is you pull us into the next company? Mm. And there's so much volatility in tech. 32:51 We have clients every day getting caught in layoffs, getting caught in reorgs, getting caught in- Yeah... them going and getting poached by another company. It's like there's so much shuffling. 33:00 For us to only stay, stay alive is that the, the clients love us so much that they'll bring us with them anywhere they go, and ideally we keep that, that account, they bring us to the new account. 33:09 That literally happened this past week with another one of our brand partners. So it's so important to really retain that. And the same thing as a creator. 33:15 It's like if I'm a creator and this influencer marketing manager jumps every six to 12 months, how do they love me so much to where they pull me in to different, um, different areas? 33:24 And actually, I'll give you a great example. Danielle, who run, who used to run influencer marketing at Notion, now runs- Now at Lovable... influencer marketing at Lovable. Mm-hmm. 33:32 Creator Camp is an incredible group of creators. I know for a fact that they used to do a ton of stuff at Notion. Danielle now goes to Lovable, and they just posted a video with Creator Camp. It's the same thing. 33:43 It's like how do you be that one creator where you stand the test of time because the brands love you so much that it doesn't matter where they go, they always wanna work with you because you know the content is so good, the relationship is so good, that you're out of your way to really be a great partner, versus it just, it's just transactional, you're just another one of those creators. 34:00 Yeah. Uh, I have a few more questions about your business specifically, but one more kinda meta level about the industry, right? 34:06 You started on LinkedIn, and now you serve, you serve brands with creators who are across platforms, right? But I'm interested in, in as much as you've seen it, differences in the B2B creator landscape across platforms. 34:19 I would imagine LinkedIn is still the core, but obviously Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, whatever, they're all growing as B2B platforms. They're all everything platforms. 34:28 But anything you can give us about, like, audience size, B2B engagement rates, whatever meta commentary on, like, the overall platform landscape for B2B creators. So I think B2B, the, the bar is much lower. 34:42 And the, I actually think that's a really good thing because when you, when you're competing and you're trying to get those very typical budgets from those typical CPG companies, like I go back to, like, Poppy and Alex Earl at Coachella, to get invited to that Coachella house, I can only imagine how competitive it is. 34:59 Versus a lot of these B2B brands, they have more money, which is very funny. They, they have way more money. One sale could be worth tens of thousands of dollars versus selling one can of soda. 35:12 And the content, what they've seen or what they're used to is, is just, is just, uh, it's like zero. It's the floor. And they're typically just running LinkedIn ads. 35:19 And you can go to that as a creator and see and get an appetite of, you know, what their ad types look like, what the content looks like. 35:26 So for B2B creators, it's very much more focused on the audience that you have, on the credibility and the influence that you have over this audience, and I think what you can pitch to the brand, because these brands now are doing a lot more in person. 35:42 A great example is, is Anthropic just did a conference in London called Code with Claude, and they worked with a couple key AI creators in London. 35:51 And again, it goes back to the, if I am the influencer marketing team at Anthropic, and I have this event, and I'm sourcing creators, what do I need to do to get on that sourcing list? 36:02 And if you are the best AI voice in London but you've never made a piece of video content, why would I hire you to come and create content that's like the come-with-me type content? 36:13 And I call it the come-with-me lifestyle content. So I think more B2B needs to adopt this come with me type content because brands are doing so much IRL now, they need an ability to, when we call the IRL to URL bridge. 36:29 So how do they take what they're doing in person, bring in creator voices into the room, creators make content about it, put it on social, and then put ad spend or media spend behind this content to have it live as long as they want for the media spend to run, right? 36:43 So if I'm a creator right now, especially in the B2B or professional AI world, is I would, I would stop just making content, let's say the talking head video in my bedroom- Mm-hmm... 36:53 but doing more of, like, showing up at these events. And, and here's a perfect example. Let's say that you're not getting paid to go somewhere, right? But you live in New York and there's Tech Week coming up. Fantastic. 37:03 There are, no joke, I think 1,000 events in the span of five days. So go make that first piece of content to when Anthropic does reach out, saying, "Hey, we're looking for creators for Code with Claude. 37:14 You know, send me in a couple examples." Send them that recap video you did from Tech Week. 37:18 It wasn't sponsored, it wasn't with Anthropic, but maybe you were at some tech events, some AI events like, "Oh my God, that is the, the style and that's the format that I want." 37:27 So, you know, I think it does come also down to, like, there's not a lot of video creators in B2B. 37:31 A lot of the B2B creators are also practitioners, which means that they have full-time jobs, so their, their volume will probably be much less. So, like, you can beat them on volume, you can beat them on, on formatting. 37:42 And just LinkedIn in general is still untapped. You have to stay consistent. The audience size on LinkedIn compared to Instagram is, like, you could say 50,000 on LinkedIn is probably worth, 37:54 I don't know, 200,000 on Instagram, maybe a million on TikTok, maybe 100,000 on, on YouTube. Like, the, the value is so high. I mean, in my audience- Mm-hmm... 38:04 on LinkedIn, I have CMOs, C-suite, CEOs, heads of marketing, heads of influencer marketing following me. That's very valuable, and you can show that audience, uh, demographic from your profile page with brands as well. 38:15 So those are some things that I'm thinking about. Obviously, the CPM is much higher. 38:19 The engagement rate is typically lower, but the content, if brands like it, they will pay for it, especially in the B2B fashion, 'cause, like, one sale could be worth so much money. Yeah. 38:28 What I'm hearing here too is that it's still a much less saturated landscape total than any other sort of creator, like CPG, lifestyle, et cetera. 38:39 B2B is still much less saturated, but, you know, I'm also hearing that it's not necessarily going to get more saturated. 38:45 The bar is going to, to raise, and it is going to be more competitive, but because it, it's, there's always more authority and experience required for the audience to believe you, for the brands to trust you, like, it's never going to be so competitive and anybody entering the space as a B2B creator looking to make money from, f- from, uh, sponsorship deals, like, they, their rates are not going to drop a lot because the competition is not going to increase that much. 39:11 It is very authoritative based on LinkedIn without a doubt, or just B2B in general, which is why, you know, the, the whole example of, like, AI generated creators and, like, mass volume of low quality UGC won't really ever work on platforms like LinkedIn because that's not what drives buyer decisions. 39:31 Mm-hmm. It's because they saw one very low quality piece of TikTok content that's like, "Oh, that's why I'm gonna go with Salesforce instead of HubSpot," right? 39:38 It's because the CMO that you follow who also creates content is talking about the use cases, again, use case marketing, talking about the use cases of how I use Salesforce's new agentic workflow and that's why I switched from a HubSpot is just an example, right? 39:52 It is very much authoritative based. So if you don't have authority, I would ask you how to build authority. 39:57 And if you have authority, I would ask you how you spend some time to create content outside of your full-time job, because that content is what moves the needle today. 40:03 And I literally spoke, I have a series called CMO Confessions. 40:06 I spoke to so many marketing teams, especially CMOs, on a daily or weekly basis, and I'm really hearing what is changing, how money's moving, how spend is shifting. 40:15 And one of the biggest trends that I've seen is that they literally said and confirmed that what they've been building for the last 10 years can be built now in a week in terms of product. Got it. 40:24 So as the barrier to build has gone to zero, especially with the rise of, of vibe coding and non-technical people building technical things, the only last moat left is brand. And brand has never been more important. 40:37 And the way, like, one of the many ways to build your brand is through an ecosystem. And I always joke that, like, creator match, the biz that we're really in is world building. 40:46 You wanna build your world through trusted voices- Mm-hmm... through creator marketing, right? Ecosystem or creator marketing. So if I'm a creator, how can I help these brands build their world? 40:55 Can I pitch them unique concepts? Can I do my research and say, "Hey, Salesforce, you have a massive conference called Dreamforce. Every year, I think it's in September in SF, right? SF and September are coming up. 41:06 I wanna pitch you an idea where I have three other creator friends that I work with. 41:10 We wanna pitch you a $50,000 campaign where we're gonna come out and create content about the event and so on and so forth, and we'll put ad spend behind it and do multi-channel." 41:18 Like, that, I think, is what's winning, less of just, "Hey, work with me and pay me for one post for, for one output," but doing your research to know what they, what they want. 41:26 So, you know, we're seeing the shift from demand to brand. Mm. 41:30 Influencer dollars are moving from, like, it's just a performance channel demand generation to brand generation, and using creators to tell that story of why Lovable is different than Bolt, different than, you know, Cursor, than Replit. 41:42 'Cause then, like, they're all underlying the same technology, but, like, how does it make you feel- Yeah... from the creators that you follow? Demand generation to brand generation is, is a good line. 41:50 Uh, so kudos to you. AJ, thank you for coming on. Of course. Been an absolute pleasure. And again, I, I wanna remind the audience that this is not an example where Francis reached out to me. 41:59 I, I reached out to Francis probably too many times and pitched him multiple times, and, you know, after about a year, finally got on the show, which has been a true honor and a true pleasure. 42:07 And continue to shoot your shot. No one's gonna come save you. No one's gonna reach out to you. Go out and, and shoot your shot and, and the world is up for grabs, and Let, let me- And, uh... let me clarify though. 42:16 Y- again, it was a very good pitch. There are plenty of pitches that I just don't have time to respond to, right? 42:20 I look at them and I think, "This is, like, this, this didn't respect my time, so I don't necessarily need to respond," right? But again, you made it very easy. Amazing. Thanks so much, Francis. 42:30 Absolute pleasure to be on the show. Mm-hmm. And audience, we will see you next week. Thank you for listening. [outro jingle] Hi there, my name's Tom. I'm the producer of the Creative Spotlight podcast. 42:39 If you enjoyed that episode and are looking for another similar one, I'd recommend this episode with Vin Matano. He runs a very similar company to AJ, a B2B creator marketing agency. 42:50 So he gets into that, but he also tells us how he makes over $200,000 a year as a creator himself, posting on LinkedIn and YouTube and so on. It's a great episode. Listen to that one next. [outro jingle]